I do think this is as close to a perfect one-off series as you can find. It's a classic now.
I wouldn't have believed it was possible. Keeping Bats out of it, I think, really helped.
The Penguin (The Batman) limited series | HBO Max
- Thread starter chrisstbh
- Start date
Help Support Collector Freaks Forum:
I do think this is as close to a perfect one-off series as you can find. It's a classic now.
I wouldn't have believed it was possible. Keeping Bats out of it, I think, really helped.
Maybe this is the Golden Age for... Gotham City.
I can't believe how well they nailed every element of this series. Even freaking kid Penguin was awesome!
Just finished the last episode. It's as close to perfect as we could have hoped for. A few times I was close to rooting for Penguin then the writers remind you just how despicable he is. A final shot of Batman on a nearby rooftop or at least his silhouette would have been the cherry on the cake but I guess what they did made the point.
It leaves me wishing we got a similar series for Batman rather than another PG-13 movie. His more gritty, detective take on the character feels better suited to an 8 hour series like this than a $200m+ movie focussed on big set pieces.
It leaves me wishing we got a similar series for Batman rather than another PG-13 movie. His more gritty, detective take on the character feels better suited to an 8 hour series like this than a $200m+ movie focussed on big set pieces.
jye4ever
Broke and happy
Batman….on TV…..used to be a sacrilegious thought for me.
But I’ve softened up on that idea over the years.
This show did an amazing job of making me change who I was rooting for from episode to episode, sometimes from scene to scene! Colin Farrell and Cristin Milioti were fantastic!
jye4ever
Broke and happy
You did see the Bat signal in the very last shot, right?
jye4ever
Broke and happy
That’s what he meant with “what they did made the point”.
I did.
I rather like the simplicity of the Batsignal.
Wonderful show with great characters and a great ending. Can't ask for more than that. This is definitely one of the best comic TV shows I've seen. Up there with Legion and the better parts of Daredevil.
jye4ever
Broke and happy
It was Penguin all along.
Johnny1378
Super Freak
- Joined
- Jun 21, 2013
- Messages
- 719
- Reaction score
- 131
Not enough vomiting of sewer sludge at the end. And the guy didn’t even have flipper for hands!
Just kidding, I liked it. Actually, I liked it better than “The Batman.”
Just kidding, I liked it. Actually, I liked it better than “The Batman.”
They went out with a bang all right, and IMO dethroned Netflix DD as the best comic book series ever.
intothevoid
Super Freak
It certainly was an improvement upon The Batman for me. The film has higher production value which is natural and that’s largely due to it having one of the best DoP's working today on the team. The show however, has an outstanding storyline and characters that get you invested in them a lot more than any of the characters in the film do.
Last edited:
I think we’ve really started to see a shift in storytelling in Hollywood over the last several years. For the longest time film was the medium to tell character driven stories and TV was a home for game shows, cartoons, and meaningless entertainment. Now I think they are starting to get that film is more of an event type experience and television can have the spacing for great character development. Taking an hour out of a movie for a flashback on the antagonist doesn’t work but was used very effectively here for a TV show. The series was stronger for it but a movie would have suffered and gotten bogged down.
It’s more important than ever to choose the right medium for the story being told. So many books were done a disservice by being adapted into movies instead of TV mini series or full series. Not everything can be told in 2 hours. But not everything can be stretched into an 8 episode season of television either. The Penguin didn’t need to be a movie to be impactful or meaningful. TV isn’t a lesser medium because it’s not a theater presentation. I so love that we are seeing programming for TV at the same, or sometimes even better, caliber as a film.
It’s more important than ever to choose the right medium for the story being told. So many books were done a disservice by being adapted into movies instead of TV mini series or full series. Not everything can be told in 2 hours. But not everything can be stretched into an 8 episode season of television either. The Penguin didn’t need to be a movie to be impactful or meaningful. TV isn’t a lesser medium because it’s not a theater presentation. I so love that we are seeing programming for TV at the same, or sometimes even better, caliber as a film.
intothevoid
Super Freak
100%
It’s extraordinary how much quality of TV shows have gone up in the last 10-15 years and equally extraordinary how the quality of the average film has plummeted
That's the saddest part for me... coming from the generation that relished movies and movie-going.
Similar threads
