Well I can't honestly saw with Sideshow that I don't feel it's a matter of how well known a character is before they make it. Look at Venomasaurus, a lot of people were like "what is this from?" Same with Darth Talon, a lot of the posts on that thread were along the lines of "Damn she's hot, ORDERED...who is she again?"
I feel like if it's done right, and looks good, they will have a hit on their hands, but it's all just wishful thinking I suppose.
Darth Talon has caused me to trust SS's judgement in what deserves the PF treatment. Darth Maul came from prettymuch nowhere to become one of the most recognizable figures in the star wars universe. Why? because in universe of very unique characters, darth maul was arguably the most unique one out there. Two-bladed saber, tattoos, blood-red skin, the first true sith in cinema...
he was godlike .
Darth Talon did a Darth Maul all over again. A Lethan Twi'lek (red skin made her ultra rare for her species), a unique saber with that organic-type hilt, tattoos, skimpy attire (rare for both sith and jedi). And she was Sith. Like Maul.
Yes, she wasn't well-known; but if there was any one character in the star wars universe that could be snatched from "obscurity" and made a smash-hit in PF, it probably was Talon. SS capitalized; I'd like to think it wasn't pure chance, but that they did their homework...
The question we need to ask is if Beta Ray could have the same effect, the same reception, if he's made into a $300 PF today. Is he unique enough to have that instant wow factor? Bowen's Beta Ray evoked some very mixed responses if I recall. I remember a few peeps here calling him "Thor with a horse head" (paraphrased)
Personally I'll buy a Sideshow Beta Ray PF in a heartbeart if he's done right; but how many others will? My mind keeps going back to Black Panther... for sheer presence, few sideshow pieces beat him, period. Yet he wasn't well-recieved. Most of the freaks think he's cool; but that they don't know him well enough to bite