Clone Wars: Thumbs up or down?

[Khev]

If you've seen Clone Wars, would you give it thumbs up or thumbs down?

 

[The Josh]

Thumbs up for me.

 

[praxitas]

Thumbs up for me as well.

 

[IrishJedi]

Gotta go with DOWN.

I'll give it another chance when the TV show hits, though.

 

[YoNoSe]

Big thumbs up! Can't wait for the sereis.

 

[Rogue Trooper]

I gave it a thumbs up, you should add a thumb sideways.

 

[Darth Snoopy]

Took my Sith Apprentices (Nieces) to see it...We all loved it.!

 

[DarthNeil]

Voted thumbs up.

 

[jsjedi]

Thumbs down cuz there is no thumbs middle. I will watch the tv show though. But if you take the kids they will love it!

 

[Deak Starkiller]

Thumbs down, anyone being honest with themselves can't look past the hollowness that is the CloneWars. But hey what do I know, I love the 1987 Masters of the Universe movie . Where is the option for "Thumbs Middle"?

 

[adambadadam]

....what did you'all expect from me???

 

[The Josh]

Thumbs down, anyone being honest with themselves can't look past the hollowness that is the CloneWars. But hey what do I know, I love the 1987 Masters of the Universe movie . Where is the option for "Thumbs Middle"?

I am being honest with myself. I liked it.

I also liked the He-Man movie.

 

[jstep13]

What was wrong with it? too kiddie? Sorry I try to stay away from the spoilers til I can see the movie...

 

[The Josh]

What was wrong with it?

Star Wars fans.

 

[Deak Starkiller]

I am being honest with myself. I liked it.

I also liked the He-Man movie.

Come on Josh, really? Skyguy? Artooie? Stinky? All bad choices on top of the already paper thin story. I love SW more than anything else (moviewise) and I had a hard time selling it to myself. But you like the MOTU film, so you're still all right.

 

[Rook]

Thumbs down, anyone being honest with themselves can't look past the hollowness that is the CloneWars.

That's an irrational statement if ever there was one. And kinda insulting, if one were inclined to look at it closely. Kinda like saying, "Anyone who liked Clone Wars is stupid." There's a phrase for that kind of poor logic: ad hominem. It diminishes the person whose argument differs from yours on the basis of your claim that all such people are dishonest with themselves, hence their arguments have no weight. Which is ridiculous.

My opinions and arguments are clearly stated in my blog at The Collective. Again, click the banner below.

EDIT: Just so ya know, Deak, I ain't tryin' ta pick a fight.

 

[The Josh]

Come on Josh, really? Skyguy? Artooie? Stinky? All bad choices on top of the already paper thin story. I love SW more than anything else (moviewise) and I had a hard time selling it to myself. But you like the MOTU film, so you're still all right.

Yeah, I really liked it. There where things that went a time or two too far but overall I had a really good time. I look forward to the series now more so than when I went in.

 

[galactiboy]

Thumbs up... if you have a problem with that then stick your thumbs up your donkey

 

[Rook]

Yeah, I really liked it. There where things that went a time or two too far but overall I had a really good time. I look forward to the series now more so than when I went in.

Word to The Josh.

 

[adambadadam]

That's an irrational statement if ever there was one. And kinda insulting, if one were inclined to look at it closely. Kinda like saying, "Anyone who liked Clone Wars is stupid." There's a phrase for that kind of poor logic: ad hominem. It diminishes the person whose argument differs from yours on the basis of your claim that all such people are dishonest with themselves, hence their arguments have no weight. Which is ridiculous.

My opinions and arguments are clearly stated in my blog at The Collective. Again, click the banner below.

EDIT: Just so ya know, Deak, I ain't tryin' ta pick a fight.

But you did do your homework, so that makes you my hero for the day!

However, it's getting a little thick in here, so that may or may not be a good thing