Fair assessment. Just curious, why weren't you blown away?
I actually never planned on getting this statue and planned on getting the Prime 1 with the new headsculpt, but after ordering JND's Batman and now seeing pics of this in-hand, I really want this and feel that it would make a better pairing with JND's Batman. Unsure if I'm still gonna get Prime 1's Joker, but I do think it's the better piece with the new headsculpt.
You ask a really tough question and my reply takes into consideration what I have received this year and the cost comparison. Prices are approximate and include UK duty.
this year I have received:
Q Collectibles 1/4 Judge Dredd £740
TweeterHead 1/5 Hordak exclusive £475
QS 1/3 Batman Premium £1100
Prime 1 1/4 Alita Deluxe £800
Prime 1 JH Predator £2000
Pure arts 1/3 Stormtrooper £600
Iron Studios 1/4 Mandalorian £800
Sideshow 1/4 Silver Surfer Exclusive £540
JND 1/3 Joker £2275
When comparing companies and scales it’s like comparing apples to oranges and whilst cost is measurable no one can assign a measure to their own opinion and the emotional connection they feel.
Firstly the packaging. I first purchased a Cinemaquette around 15 years ago who were doing the solid coffin box, straps etc. So the packaging for me is nothing new or not what I would call a game changer. JND has really nice packaging which in this instance is very compact but no longer anything special. Q Collectibles Judge Dredd and Pure Arts Stormtrooper almost equal to it in regards to what I have received this year and at a third of the cost. It can be argued that JND box is more classy.
Unboxing: For me it was like unboxing a Hot Toy Quarter Scale figure. The Gun and Knife feel plastic and for a premium brand I would expect a metal finish. Tailoring is nice and requires Futzing.
Quality Control: my left foot is loose. I have seen post where the left foot became detached at the ankle due to what appears a lack of Glue. For me JND have to have perfect QC to be the leading premium brand.
is it the best value statue I have received this year. Without a doubt NO. Tweeterhead Hordak, Q Judge Dredd, PureArts Stormtrooper all IMHO easily beat it for the price I paid.
Is it the best Quality statue I have received this year. Again NO. That easily goes to Q Judge Dredd. Simply amazing Paint Apps and overall quality.
is it the best statue I have received this year. No. I would have equal arguments for IS Mandalorian, TH Ex Hordak and Q Judge Dredd. I love them all when considering the cost and overall quality.
Conclusion. This is where personal emotion comes into play. Regardless of everything I have just said above and in my previous posts I absolutely LOVE this statue. If I had to choose and only keep one statue from this year it would be JND Ledger Joker. This conclusion will make no sense but it’s the feeling I get from when I look at the raw intensity from the Joker portrait. Nothing matches it in terms of the connection I feel.
Should you buy it. Your Choice. Unfortunately, I doubt my reply will help you decide. My only advice is decide quickly!