The Walking Dead - TV Series on AMC ( Comic and Un-aired Spoilers unwelcome!)

[quadcent]

i think the blood in the car seat indicated that judith is a goner

yeah but that's to easy to assume. I think someone that was all bloody from the battle probably grabbed her.

 

[Mister Ski]

I think Judith could be alive.

Kirkman didn't deny it well.

yeah but that's to easy to assume. I think someone that was all bloody from the battle probably grabbed her.

Just re-watched the scene where Carl and Rick find Judith's carrier. I think she is still alive. The buckle that straps Judith in was undone. A Walker wouldn't have done that. Someone grabbed her and my money is on Tara.

 

[The Ween]

There were 4 kids together with Judith then Judith was gone and so were 2 of the girls. I wonder if they're with Tara.

 

[menoseloso]

Just re-watched the scene where Carl and Rick find Judith's carrier. I think she is still alive. The buckle that straps Judith in was undone. A Walker wouldn't have done that. Someone grabbed her and my money is on Tara.

Yeah I noticed that too. And if she is dead, I don't think we've seen the last of her. Kirkman said

Spoiler

We'd see a zombie baby at some point this season, so I wouldn't be surprised at this point if that turns out to be Judith. But I kind of doubt it would be her at the same time. I just don't see him giving away that big of a spoiler.

 

[The Ween]

Michonne showed so much emotion holding her. Too bad she doesn't have her, though I don't think she went that far back into the prison.

 

[Mister Ski]

Michonne showed so much emotion holding her. Too bad she doesn't have her, though I don't think she went that far back into the prison.

Right. I thought about Michonne having Judith, but it doesn't not seem possible.

We see Michonne save Rick from the Governor. Rick asks her where Carl is. Michonne stays behind to look the Governor over one last time while Rick climbs the hill to the prison, finds Carl near the tank and goes around the corner to find Judith baby seat. There is no way Michonne could have got to Judith before Rick and Carl or without them seeing her.

 

[Tornadoflame]

Right. I thought about Michonne having Judith, but it doesn't not seem possible.

We see Michonne save Rick from the Governor. Rick asks her where Carl is. Michonne stays behind to look the Governor over one last time while Rick climbs the hill to the prison, finds Carl near the tank and goes around the corner to find Judith baby seat. There is no way Michonne could have got to Judith before Rick and Carl or without them seeing her.

Maggie went looking for Judith. We haven't seen either since.

 

[Mister Ski]

Maggie went looking for Judith. We haven't seen either since.

I thought Maggie went looking for Beth (who was looking for Judith), ran into Sasha and Bob and left with them right after the bus took off.

 

[Sachiel]

I think if anyone has her it's Tyreese and the girls. He said they had to leave, then the girls ran and he said that was the wrong way. They probably went back for her.

 

[a-dev]

Eventually got it finished.

Exciting episode, can't say it played out exactly how I'd have liked. Rick pretty much getting pwned by the Gov, I didn't like. Rick crying again for the remainder of his scenes, I mean, maybe its understandable but I hope after this he'll harden up again.

The Governor's characterisation was bizarre. He seems almost reasonable when he's alone with Michonne and Hershel in his camper van - when he had no need to be. None of his people were around that he had to pretend to be sane. Then he's out lifting up and hugging his new 'daughter'.

Next thing outside the prison he's semi-decapitating Hershel. The battle begins and people take cover. The Governor sees Hershel is still alive and despite the fact the battle is afoot he takes the time to put him out of his misery. Why?
Then along comes whatshername with her dying daughter and the Gov just coldly walks over and immediately shoots the girl in the head, without expressing a modicum of emotion. Back to the fight......Ok? So no plans to preserve that particular relationship even if he does manage to take the prison.

And to top it all off the whole enterprise seems to be a failure for the Gov's group, despite the emphasis on their superior numbers and firepower. Looks like they all end up being killed. So in fact no one will end up staying in the prison.

I dunno, exciting but in some parts puzzling.

 

[Avfin]

I gotta say Maggie was hot hot hot this episode

Sent from my PH44100 using Tapatalk 2

 

[Mister Ski]

Eventually got it finished.

Exciting episode, can't say it played out exactly how I'd have liked. Rick pretty much getting pwned by the Gov, I didn't like. Rick crying again for the remainder of his scenes, I mean, maybe its understandable but I hope after this he'll harden up again.

The Governor's characterisation was bizarre. He seems almost reasonable when he's alone with Michonne and Hershel in his camper van - when he had no need to be. None of his people were around that he had to pretend to be sane. Then he's out lifting up and hugging his new 'daughter'.

Next thing outside the prison he's semi-decapitating Hershel. The battle begins and people take cover. The Governor sees Hershel is still alive and despite the fact the battle is afoot he takes the time to put him out of his misery. Why?
Then along comes whatshername with her dying daughter and the Gov just coldly walks over and immediately shoots the girl in the head, without expressing a modicum of emotion. Back to the fight......Ok? So no plans to preserve that particular relationship even he does manage to take the prison.

And to top it all off the whole enterprise seems to be a failure for the Gov's group, despite the emphasis on their superior numbers and firepower. Looks like they all end up being killed. So in fact no one will end up staying in the prison.

I dunno, exciting but in some parts puzzling.

Rick got some good licks in despite a bad hand (from his smack down with Tyreese) and getting shot in the leg. Kirkman said he wanted Rick, Michonne and Lilly to all have a hand in the Governor's death. Personally, I wish it was Rick who ended up doing the deed too.

I didn't perceive the Governor as reasonable when talking with Michonne and Hershel, just calm. If he was reasonable he would have considered first Hershel's and then Rick's offer to share the prison. I also don't think the Governor had any real feeling for Lilly outside of her being Meghan's mom. She was a means to an end in that a relationship with Lilly meant one with Meghan too. Once Meghan was dead, so too was any hope he had of having a family again. I think she was already dead when Lilly brought her to the Governor and he just finished the deed so she wouldn't re-animate.

Yeah the Governor's group was a group of mindless sheep. I find it hard to believe this group of people survived for as long as they did with no individual thinkers in the group. Trusting a guy they have known for less than a week and then sticking by him after they see him decapitate a defenseless old man? Wasn't sad to see any of them go. I am pretty sure we have not seen the last of Lilly and Tara though, so technically two from the Governor's group survived.

 

[ExMem-LarjaThwei]

Eventually got it finished.

Exciting episode, can't say it played out exactly how I'd have liked. Rick pretty much getting pwned by the Gov, I didn't like. Rick crying again for the remainder of his scenes, I mean, maybe its understandable but I hope after this he'll harden up again.

The Governor's characterisation was bizarre. He seems almost reasonable when he's alone with Michonne and Hershel in his camper van - when he had no need to be. None of his people were around that he had to pretend to be sane. Then he's out lifting up and hugging his new 'daughter'.

Next thing outside the prison he's semi-decapitating Hershel. The battle begins and people take cover. The Governor sees Hershel is still alive and despite the fact the battle is afoot he takes the time to put him out of his misery. Why?
Then along comes whatshername with her dying daughter and the Gov just coldly walks over and immediately shoots the girl in the head, without expressing a modicum of emotion. Back to the fight......Ok? So no plans to preserve that particular relationship even he does manage to take the prison.

And to top it all off the whole enterprise seems to be a failure for the Gov's group, despite the emphasis on their superior numbers and firepower. Looks like they all end up being killed. So in fact no one will end up staying in the prison.

I dunno, exciting but in some parts puzzling.

Agreed. The ending battle was...odd.

I still am not buying that all of these random people would so easily side with the Governor. Especially after they saw Rick, learned that there were children in the prison, etc. They've known the Governor for what? Maybe a week? He takes innocent people hostage and decapitates one of them, a seemingly kind and harmless old man and they're all on board with that? Yeah, okay.

The last two Governor-focused episodes were fantastic IMO, but they just wasted all that potential with this finale. Bleh.

Also agree about Rick. I wish he would have beat the Governor senseless. You'd think he would have come out on top in that fight, especially with all the rage he must have been feeling after seeing Hershel's death.

I'm tired of Rick always crying. He's a good actor and cries like a pro, but I want to see him take control again and stop moping around every episode.

 

[Sachiel]

 

[neo]

Agreed. The ending battle was...odd.

I still am not buying that all of these random people would so easily side with the Governor. Especially after they saw Rick, learned that there were children in the prison, etc. They've known the Governor for what? Maybe a week? He takes innocent people hostage and decapitates one of them, a seemingly kind and harmless old man and they're all on board with that? Yeah, okay.

The last two Governor-focused episodes were fantastic IMO, but they just wasted all that potential with this finale. Bleh.

Also agree about Rick. I wish he would have beat the Governor senseless. You'd think he would have come out on top in that fight, especially with all the rage he must have been feeling after seeing Hershel's death.

I'm tired of Rick always crying. He's a good actor and cries like a pro, but I want to see him take control again and stop moping around every episode.

just poor writing as usual..

 

[Snake Plissken]

Didn't take long

 

[SnakeDoctor]

SnakeDoc

 

[quadcent]

SnakeDoc

I was really surprised that they had this much action and closure in one episode. thought for sure that they would of halted it in the middle of the assault or at the beginning, so to leave everyone hanging till the next start up in Feb.

 

[quadcent]

Agreed. The ending battle was...odd.

I still am not buying that all of these random people would so easily side with the Governor. Especially after they saw Rick, learned that there were children in the prison, etc. They've known the Governor for what? Maybe a week? He takes innocent people hostage and decapitates one of them, a seemingly kind and harmless old man and they're all on board with that? Yeah, okay.

The last two Governor-focused episodes were fantastic IMO, but they just wasted all that potential with this finale. Bleh.

Also agree about Rick. I wish he would have beat the Governor senseless. You'd think he would have come out on top in that fight, especially with all the rage he must have been feeling after seeing Hershel's death.

I'm tired of Rick always crying. He's a good actor and cries like a pro, but I want to see him take control again and stop moping around every episode.

wasn't rick shot though??? don't think the Gov was hurt at all to that point.

 

[Mister Ski]

wasn't rick shot though??? don't think the Gov was hurt at all to that point.

I think the Governor got shot in the arm right after cutting into Hershel's neck the first time. Still, I agree that Rick was in worse shape since he had a gun shot wound to the leg and his hand still wasn't healed from his fight with Tyreese.