Two Planet Hulk questions

[JAWS]

First question - Does anyone have a comparison picture of the Green Scar vs the Silver Savage Dio with any comiquettes, Pfs of Bowen FS. I have read great things about this piece but many have said it's a tad small.


Second question - What incarnation of Hulks personality is Planet Hulk/WWH. I know he is not prof. hulk but he is not the savage or dumb hulk. I have read the stories before PH and after. Both incarnations seemed to have been the more child like "hulk smash" hulk. I know there have been times when the Hulk has had better speaking abilities but what is that part of Hulks personality called?



Thanks!

 

[Mr. Green]

Green Scar is definitely bigger than Dynamic Force's Hulk, by Pablo Viggiano, but little smaller than Bowen's Red Hulk.

I don't think PH/WWH is a new personality Hulk - just the same Hulk but little smarter/wiser than before. Just a little bit of Fixit and Prof Hulk. Without his savage side he wouldn't be the strongest personality there is.

 

[FQRizzo]

I have both the SS dio and the Bowen FS and the Bowen is definitely bigger. As for which one is better, they both have their own qualities.

I'd argue that Planet Hulk is a unique personality. Savage, yet not stupid.

 

[JAWS]

I'd argue that Planet Hulk is a unique personality. Savage, yet not stupid.

That is how I think of it. I just could not remember if that side of Hulk has ever been around before. I have read a lot of hulk comics and i did not recall that side of him. I am now reading PH for the second time and just got thinking about it again.

 

[JAWS]

I don't think PH/WWH is a new personality Hulk - just the same Hulk but little smarter/wiser than before. Just a little bit of Fixit and Prof Hulk. Without his savage side he wouldn't be the strongest personality there is.

I don't know. He seemed pretty strong in PH and laid waste to much of the marvel Universe with ease. X-men did not stand a chance. i think this was a more cruel Hulk. because he was smarter then savage hulk he could be more cruel and because he he was feeding off his emotions (anger) he was more savage and thus stronger then prof hulk and fixit. In My opinion anyways.

Either way it's just such a great story

 

[RaZaTrOn]

After Planet Hulk, Hulk named himself Green Scar. That is the Hulk we see all through the saga.

He is the worse Hulk personality for people because he is stronger yet remains calm. Therefore his enemies don't have a chance!

 

[Mr. Green]

I don't know. He seemed pretty strong in PH and laid waste to much of the marvel Universe with ease. X-men did not stand a chance. i think this was a more cruel Hulk. because he was smarter then savage hulk he could be more cruel and because he he was feeding off his emotions (anger) he was more savage and thus stronger then prof hulk and fixit. In My opinion anyways.

Either way it's just such a great story

According to Amedeus Cho, he's not a killer and he haven't at the end. He is the same hulk that get into the space ship, planet Sakaar, and eventual return to Earth. Hulk evolved physically and also mentally. He did get some help from his warbound warriors. The prist warbound helped him mentally which helped alot against Dr. Strange. In the end, I think he's the same savage Hulk that evolved. He is still the strongest personality; stronger than the darkest hulk personality. I don't remember reading of any new personality during his PH/WWH.

Its possible that a unique or new personality emerges within Banner's mind that Marvel still haven't revealed yet. But I am sure any Hulk reader would know that Hulk personality reset to a dumb, savage Hulk, after WWH - Red Hulk and certainly Skaar was disgusted by this. And that Hulk personality reset again, on issue 610, as return of the Hulk. This Hulk then took down Sakaar and then Red Hulk(separately) pretty much easily. Not sure about the current Hulk as he seem to be shifting a bit; from talking to Capt A like he's under Banner's control to the savage in the Savage Land with Miek.

 

[JAWS]

According to Amedeus Cho, he's not a killer and he haven't at the end. He is the same hulk that get into the space ship, planet Sakaar, and eventual return to Earth. Hulk evolved physically and also mentally. He did get some help from his warbound warriors. The prist warbound helped him mentally which helped alot against Dr. Strange. In the end, I think he's the same savage Hulk that evolved. He is still the strongest personality; stronger than the darkest hulk personality. I don't remember reading of any new personality during his PH/WWH.

Its possible that a unique or new personality emerges within Banner's mind that Marvel still haven't revealed yet. But I am sure any Hulk reader would know that Hulk personality reset to a dumb, savage Hulk, after WWH - Red Hulk and certainly Skaar was disgusted by this. And that Hulk personality reset again, on issue 610, as return of the Hulk. This Hulk then took down Sakaar and then Red Hulk(separately) pretty much easily. Not sure about the current Hulk as he seem to be shifting a bit; from talking to Capt A like he's under Banner's control to the savage in the Savage Land with Miek.

Yes there is no mention of a new personality and perhaps all you that say is true. It's just this Hulk is so different from any other hulks I have read that I thought perhaps there was a personality I was unfamiliar with.

I think I will call this personality Super Bad Ass HULK

 

[Mr. Green]

After Planet Hulk, Hulk named himself Green Scar. That is the Hulk we see all through the saga.

He is the worse Hulk personality for people because he is stronger yet remains calm. Therefore his enemies don't have a chance!

Huh??? Are u sure? He was called green scar during the gladiator arena wasn't he? Actually, issue 93, is the first time I've read of "The Green Scar". He was battling some wildbots and specifically defeating one of em, EggBreaker, when they called him "The Green Scar". I believe he was named "Green Scar" because earlier, the emperior entered the arena and scar his cheek. The Hulk returned the favor of course.

 

[JAWS]

Huh??? Are u sure? He was called green scar during the gladiator arena wasn't he? Actually, issue 93, is the first time I've read of "The Green Scar". He was battling some wildbots and specifically defeating one of em, EggBreaker, when they called him "The Green Scar". I believe he was named "Green Scar" because earlier, the emperior entered the arena and scar his cheek. The Hulk returned the favor of course.

Yep thats what how it went down.

 

[greatwall]

 

[budafett]

This thread just got REAL

 

[JAWS]

Thanks greatwall!!!

 

[FQRizzo]

To quote a "Just for Men" commercial, that beard looks wierd.

 

[RaZaTrOn]

Huh??? Are u sure? He was called green scar during the gladiator arena wasn't he? Actually, issue 93, is the first time I've read of "The Green Scar". He was battling some wildbots and specifically defeating one of em, EggBreaker, when they called him "The Green Scar". I believe he was named "Green Scar" because earlier, the emperior entered the arena and scar his cheek. The Hulk returned the favor of course.

Yeah they called him Green Scar and the Hulk took that name upon himself when he arrived to earth.

Therefore the personality is simply referred to as the Green Scar personality because the first time it showed itself was Planet Skarr/WWH.

 

[Sweet Rabbit]

the PH/WWH hulk was pretty smart

he learned how to strategize and then attack instead of just smashing everything first

 

[Reefer Shark]

He was actually smart before PH, but not smart enough to tell they were BS'ing him with the whole "space mission" deal

 

[greatwall]

 

[greatwall]

Thanks greatwall!!!

No problem, anytime.

 

[JAWS]

Here is some info I looked up. Of course non of it is official but it sounds good to me.

From Wiki - Gravage Hulk - The Gravage Hulk is a merger of the Savage Hulk persona and the Gray Hulk persona. It was caused when Bruce Banner had control over the Hulk's personality after using his Gamma Projector. After the destruction of Sakaar, Gravage Hulk came back calling himself Green Scar. Possessing greater anger and strength than ever, this Hulk also possessed a calm, cold, calculating fury (due to the efforts of Hiroim the Shamed). Green Scar is the insanely enraged version of the Gravage Hulk. Green Scar has extremely high durability and has trained in combat arms like broadswords, spears, and battle shields. Green Scar's strength comes from the compassion with the other Hulk incarnations from within, as well as Bruce Banner supporting its actions. The Green Scar incarnation is shown to be resistant to Professor X's psionic effects and withstand Black Bolt's hypersonic voice. It later gained the "Worldbreaker" title after two battles with Skaar.




Some Fan - The Hulk has a lot of different incarnations and even from the character's inception, they constantly changed, which his most stable period being during the late 60s-the early 80s where he was the classic "Hulk Smash"/Savage Hulk personna.

But that was the Hulk's original personality. The Hulk incarnation he is in now was brought back during Peter David's last run and has appeared many times before, the first being in the early 60s when he helped found the Avengers.

This Hulk, nicknamed the "Grayvage Hulk" by fans, has the strength of the Savage Hulk, the cunning and regular intelligence of the Grey Hulk and a certain brutish independence.


Another fan site - THE "GRAVAGE" HULK - 1965
This is an early appearance of an intelligent, Green Hulk, also known as the "Gravage" Hulk, as he appeared in 1965. This version of The Hulk had the mind, intellegence & personality of the gray "Joe Fixit" Hulk, with the body of the green "Savage" Hulk, thus the term "gravage". This image is from TALES TO ASTONISH #75 (January, 1966).