The only one i've seen for real is the You Shall Not Pass Plaque.
(- it does have the crappest packaging! )
I prefer things in color, so i'd probably take it over Escape off the Road - though the faux bronze style really works for the scene being depicted.
I think the worst is meeting of old friends, which seems to have had the life drained from it. I also think the Budgie plaque could have benefited with color.
DEFINITELY Escape plaque everyone that comes to my home raves about it!! By far the best and then the Isengard plaque the other two I am not crazy about! The faux bronxe is what really makes these two plaques amazing, gives a really ancient "legend" feel to them!
Escape plaque for me too. I love the bronze look, the detail, the pose, everything. It perfectly captures that scene, one of my favorite from both movie and book (even though it is an amalgamation of two scenes from the book).
Quoted by Radagaster: "Escape is the best, and that's the reason I only got that one for now. I've seen the others at SDCC and pale in comparison to Escape."
I have not had the chance to get Escape as of yet & I have not seen one in person. My opinion was based on the ones that I have.