Prime Clone
Super Freak
Well, which one?
Which saga had the most disappointing conclusion?
- Thread starter Prime Clone
- Start date
Help Support Collector Freaks Forum:
WhoaItsJBot
Super Freak
I'd say GoT S8 was the worst, followed closely by Endgame. I'm not even gonna bother watching Ep 9, since I don't care for Disney's Star Wars at all.
dan350zr
Super Freak
Lost had a horrible ending (thanks JJ Abrams)... but yeah Game of Thrones was pretty bad, it was rushed and the fact they let someone who was in prison determine who would be the new King spoke volumes to how absurd it bacame... The Rise of Skywalker was pretty lame also but Kenndy got what she wanted, to show that a female would make the most powerful Jedi ever... Not even Yoda could come close to her powers...
Mandible
Super Freak
- Joined
- Jul 16, 2010
- Messages
- 3,522
- Reaction score
- 1,737
I didn't really like TROS, but man, did I feel sorry for JJ and the whole team, with what they were left to work with. I think if he had have overseen (at the very least) the story, we wouldn't be in the situation we're in. Even the editor of TROS has ripped Ruin for abandoning storylines.
So with that in mind - GOT trumps it.
I really admire D&D that they admitted they ****ed up and they were out of their league by the end, but regardless, it was a shocker; like a whole different show by the last 2 seasons.
So with that in mind - GOT trumps it.
I really admire D&D that they admitted they ****ed up and they were out of their league by the end, but regardless, it was a shocker; like a whole different show by the last 2 seasons.
The Clown Prince of Crime
Super Freak
Why is Avengers even there? 
The Clown Prince of Crime
Super Freak
The answer is SW. The new trilogy ruined the one good trilogy by making it completely pointless.
Mandible
Super Freak
- Joined
- Jul 16, 2010
- Messages
- 3,522
- Reaction score
- 1,737
Very true. But at least you can watch the OT as a stand-alone story, with a definitive conclusion, and forget the ST even exists
This is a very tough question: GoT or SW
I have lived with Star Wars much longer so it cuts deeper. Both we're pretty terrible.
I have lived with Star Wars much longer so it cuts deeper. Both we're pretty terrible.
Yeah but only if I'm unable to divorce myself from what is considered 'official canon'. But I've been doing that since the PT and I'm simply doing it again with the ST.
Meanwhile those who like the ST probably don't even agree that it makes the preceding films pointless.
I must have missed that.
Very true. But at least you can watch the OT as a stand-alone story, with a definitive conclusion, and forget the ST even exists
Yeah. So I'm going to agree - Game of Thrones.
I enjoyed watching the final season as it happened - with members of the family gathered together for it - but on reflection I don't like what actually happened and it really does make it less likely that I'd go back and rewatch everything through again knowing that the ending was such a bitter pill. Even if it had more time to be developed I'm not sure I ever would have liked Dany going full dark-side. Jaime and Cersei's demise was lame.
It wasn't totally devoid of merit - as usual the spectacle was incredible (when you could see it) and I think the conclusion of Clegganebowl was good, great acting by everyone etc.
That's true. But then, people still believe the world is flat but that doesn't make them right.
Otomofan
Super Freak
- Joined
- Nov 8, 2009
- Messages
- 5,217
- Reaction score
- 4,044
Star Wars ending beautifully with ROTJ in 1983.
GoT was way too rushed but I have no problem with the actual content of the story.
Avengers was a silly ending. Convoluted time travel mess and killing off/retiring characters just cause the actors' contracts were up. Terrible ending.
GoT was way too rushed but I have no problem with the actual content of the story.
Avengers was a silly ending. Convoluted time travel mess and killing off/retiring characters just cause the actors' contracts were up. Terrible ending.
jkno
Stormtrooper
OT ended pretty cool, despite ROTJ's flaws - wish I'd be able to go into a parallel universe where the Ewoks are replaced by Wookiees though. The Sequel Trilogy is no fun, it's an amateurish high budget series of movies slapped together without any story arc, nothing, just politically correctness crap all day long.
I liked Rogue One and Mando, Solo was ok. But in the end:
Close second comes Game of Thrones, such a big disappointment there too, a rushed final season, with glimpses of that rushing already in earlier seasons. Sad
I liked Rogue One and Mando, Solo was ok. But in the end:
Close second comes Game of Thrones, such a big disappointment there too, a rushed final season, with glimpses of that rushing already in earlier seasons. Sad
Prime Clone
Super Freak
Why is Avengers even there?
Because it was one of the big three sagas that concluded this year, and many thought EG was a disappointment after IW.
IW was a better movie than Endgame but I definitely wasn’t disappointed in how it all got wrapped up.
SW for the win even though I’ll be striking it from canon.
SW for the win even though I’ll be striking it from canon.
WhoaItsJBot
Super Freak
I despise everything about the ST, from the characters to the events, but rather than waste energy hating it constantly I've just decided to pretend the Disney films don't exist.
I've been a huge fan of the EU for the past 15+ years, so in my mind that is still canon.
The Clown Prince of Crime
Super Freak
I saw people disappointed with Hulk. I'm one of them, but there was no real backlash like GOT and SW.
WhoaItsJBot
Super Freak
Disappointed with Hulk, Thor, and I didn't care for the time travel nonsense at all. There isn't much memorable about Endgame at all to me, except perhaps Cap finally wielding Mjolnir.
Similar threads
