DUNE: Prophecy (HBO/Max Prequel Series)
- Thread starter chrisstbh
- Start date
Help Support Collector Freaks Forum:
Frank Herbert woke?!?!More witchy strong girl power
*Brian Herbert
Frank created the Bene Gesserit. They were always a society of powerful women.
Don’t cry about it.
- Joined
- Dec 12, 2023
- Messages
- 572
- Reaction score
- 352
More witchy strong girl power
Is there something else from the Dune universe you would have preferred?
- Joined
- Jul 22, 2006
- Messages
- 5,485
- Reaction score
- 454
I'll give it a spin.Have only read Dune and Dune Messiah. Children of Dune is supposed to be good, but after that the storytelling apparently goes off the deep end. It looks like they're tying into the movie aesthetics and streamlining the storytelling so it could be cool.
- Joined
- May 31, 2011
- Messages
- 19,883
- Reaction score
- 291
I’ve only read the first two as well, I have to admit the trailer was pretty good and I’m looking forward to trying it out.
D U N E
Sex and Babies
H B O
Sex and Babies
H B O
histrionics
Super Freak
- Joined
- Jun 25, 2010
- Messages
- 276
- Reaction score
- 392
It might be watchable. I don't see the premature "woke" accusations when the Bene Gesserit storyline is so significant in Dune - If you really want to make those accusations then you'd have to do so with fairness throughout the Herbert Dune legacy dating back decades. There's a lot of it there to critique, if you choose to do that.
This is going to be about writing and performances more than anything else. Can the Dune legacy hold up on a small screen, or will it fall apart? This won't be Villeneuve's Dune and I just find that small screen series adaptations tend to be a bit cheap looking and fall short of the cinematic impressiveness that they piggyback off of. That's the nature of small scaled, lower budget TV adaptations. It will struggle to maintain the same level of world-building that Villeneuve succeeded with, so when production values suffer they have to survive on writing and performances more than anything.
A series like this is more of a literary reason to watch Dune than a cinematic one. We have more episodes, an extended storyline, a lot of protracted storytelling, all stuff that we can take back and ponder over and discuss with friends/fans over many months. It's workplace water cooler banter and something we discuss over drinks and dinner. But it's the writing and story we'll be discussing more than anything else.
I already saw some visual moments that made me cringe a little. It reminded me of the old Dune and Children of Dune mini-series' that felt cheap and often voluntarily forgettable. Those series' told the story, probably as best as could be told, but didn't do the heavy lifting of a convincing and immersive world-building. Set pieces, environments, costumes, production design, special effects mostly felt decorative and struggling to assist the story. This series will glaringly be piggybacking off the success of Villeneuve's Dune films (it already looks like they lifted some visual motifs), so it has to stand on its own in terms of writing and storytelling, along with some decent actor performances to really sell the concept. I think an intimate Bene Gesserit storyline, with all of the conspiratorial, metaphysical, spiritual and downright Shakespearean machinations could be a good approach for a small screen serialized Dune. Let's see how this goes.
This is going to be about writing and performances more than anything else. Can the Dune legacy hold up on a small screen, or will it fall apart? This won't be Villeneuve's Dune and I just find that small screen series adaptations tend to be a bit cheap looking and fall short of the cinematic impressiveness that they piggyback off of. That's the nature of small scaled, lower budget TV adaptations. It will struggle to maintain the same level of world-building that Villeneuve succeeded with, so when production values suffer they have to survive on writing and performances more than anything.
A series like this is more of a literary reason to watch Dune than a cinematic one. We have more episodes, an extended storyline, a lot of protracted storytelling, all stuff that we can take back and ponder over and discuss with friends/fans over many months. It's workplace water cooler banter and something we discuss over drinks and dinner. But it's the writing and story we'll be discussing more than anything else.
I already saw some visual moments that made me cringe a little. It reminded me of the old Dune and Children of Dune mini-series' that felt cheap and often voluntarily forgettable. Those series' told the story, probably as best as could be told, but didn't do the heavy lifting of a convincing and immersive world-building. Set pieces, environments, costumes, production design, special effects mostly felt decorative and struggling to assist the story. This series will glaringly be piggybacking off the success of Villeneuve's Dune films (it already looks like they lifted some visual motifs), so it has to stand on its own in terms of writing and storytelling, along with some decent actor performances to really sell the concept. I think an intimate Bene Gesserit storyline, with all of the conspiratorial, metaphysical, spiritual and downright Shakespearean machinations could be a good approach for a small screen serialized Dune. Let's see how this goes.
HBO tends to spend tall dollars on show production so I’d be pretty sure it’ll be on a grand scale. It’ll be interesting to see how it plays out.
There’s another cool DUNE thing going on. Funcom is in the process of making an MMO called Dune: The Awakening. Funcom’s been at it for a long time so I’m expecting good things from them. Here’s a link..
https://duneawakening.com/
There’s another cool DUNE thing going on. Funcom is in the process of making an MMO called Dune: The Awakening. Funcom’s been at it for a long time so I’m expecting good things from them. Here’s a link..
https://duneawakening.com/
- Joined
- May 31, 2011
- Messages
- 19,883
- Reaction score
- 291
I’ve been following this game closely, I’m not sold yet as Funcom can make some pretty lackluster games (Conan for example) I wish instead of the MMO route they wouldn’t went with a strictly single player game. It could be great though.
We shall see. I played Conan when it was released long ago. It was a great game in the beginning. I played Anarchy Online for several years. It was so far ahead of its time back in 2002. The trailers they’ve shown look pretty good. I’m looking forward to seeing it come to fruition. Fingers crossed
- Joined
- May 31, 2011
- Messages
- 19,883
- Reaction score
- 291
Fingers crossed indeed! The trailers has been good, as well as their communication on discord with the community. I’m really eager to see some gameplay.We shall see. I played Conan when it was released long ago. It was a great game in the beginning. I played Anarchy Online for several years. It was so far ahead of its time back in 2002. The trailers they’ve shown look pretty good. I’m looking forward to seeing it come to fruition. Fingers crossed
abake
Rex Tremendae Majestatis
The Bene Gesserit are a fascinating creation, and they are formidable at pulling the strings behind the curtains in the Herbert novels, so there's a lot to explore here...
There's some good actors attached, so hopefully it'll be good.
There's some good actors attached, so hopefully it'll be good.
The cheesy editing and sound in that trailer are off putting to me. It's the trailer version of shaky cam. If this show will have class and depth like the films, then it deserves better. But maybe they are going for more of a morbious or madame web vibe with this show.
abake
Rex Tremendae Majestatis
I liked it.
Seems to respect the aesthetics of the movies while introducing its own new visual cues. Nice world-building too. And I like that we're getting a better look at the machinations of the Bene Gesserit, which were sadly under-developed in the movies.
Seems to respect the aesthetics of the movies while introducing its own new visual cues. Nice world-building too. And I like that we're getting a better look at the machinations of the Bene Gesserit, which were sadly under-developed in the movies.
