I think we'll agree to disagree at this point.
I wish I liked the Prime 1. If I did, I'd have ordered it twice already and never looked back. Would be great to have an Alien Warrior in the collection and I envy people like Galactusz for whom either option scratches the itch. I recognize it's a more accurate sculpt by a few percentage points. Its pose is inspired by a moment in the movie, yes (although we never see its full body at that moment). The paintjob will be less of a gamble. It's certainly not a bad value in that you get a lot of polysyone for the price.
But the core design of the Prime 1, the concept itself, does absolutely nothing for me. Even if it were only $1K, I still wouldn't take it because it's too busy and feels more like a diorama than a character-centric maquette and the latter is what I'm after. I'm glad you're confident enough in your purchase to assert it so many times in the thread of another product.
The back tubes on the CP may be too small. The tubing around the base of the skull may not have rings around it (well, the raw sculpt does but they're too faint to catch the light at all). But the overall composition of the piece -- the pose and base -- is exactly what I want to see in an Alien statue. And, assuming CP nail the paint quality (which again is a gamble), the paint
scheme for their Warrior looks more impressive to me. Prime 1's is looking a little dark and I want the highlights to pop like the insects that inspired Winston's team.
It's frustrating to have to wait and see CP bumble around with the water and acid marks, but I'm in no rush to fill a gap in my collection. I'll wait as long as it takes and hopefully get something good at the end. If not, I won't buy either of them. Simple as.
I also realize I'm in a minority here.
Makes me wonder just how many CP will even produce if this thing gets off the ground. Waiting for in-hand photos might prevent me from being able to find one at all.