- Joined
- Mar 9, 2010
- Messages
- 5,818
- Reaction score
- 1,704
While I'll happily agree he's one of the best -- his Wolf and Predalien busts are my two favorite representations of those characters -- I don't think the matter is cut-and-dry when his sculpts are still a bit idealized. That gives them an undeniable appeal and helps them come alive, but it makes the movie accuracy conversation difficult.
Every Predator sculpt has its imperfections, be it the softness of the sculpt, the gesture or personality, the overall proportions, the micro details, etc. and we value each of these areas differently, making concessions in those that aren't as important to us. For you, the tubbiness of the 1/3 JH hurts the product and that's understandable. Another factor is the shady company manufacturing him, whereas Narin has rightfully earned the trust and admiration of his fans through years of top-notch artistry and reliability. It's an important factor for sure, but it's got nothing to do with sculpt. If that's our focus, no one's really nailed the character yet. Even the SWS has its well-documented issues. But we get closer each time and, hopefully, learn from what came before.*
*It certainly would be nice if the sculpt and business conversations overlapped in this aspect.
Great post.
As regards Narin's sculpts - let's limit it to the Jungle Hunter (for now) . . . I think Narin's "Encounter" and "Classic" (as HE called it - NOT the one from "Predators") - both being sculpts from 2010 . . . are spot on.
As always - each to their own - but I think they are absolute perfection as regards screen accuracy (not to mention "art direction" and casting quality, and customer service, and price [etc.])
The man (and his team) are GODS as far as I'm concerned (I mean - maybe not at Ian Kilmister level - but darned close ).
.