I wouldn't pick one over the other because they say it uses 'genuine leather'. What incentive do they have to even be honest? Looking at it logically, how are they going to use actual leather, that's thin enough, and high quality enough, and still charge less than $200?
Even the $400 custom outfits don't even use real leather, because real leather doesn't work like that. You've got your $600 Indiana Jones jacket, whose main selling point is that it's real leather, and even THAT one still has problems with thickness.
Further, I don't even know where this talk about Premier using genuine leather even got started, none of their photos or product description say it uses genuine leather. Sounds like someone just 'read it on Facebook'
Having said all that, Premier is the only one that's an original creation and not recasting someone else's custom, soooooo ......