I mean, I'm fine with folks saying they bought it for a representation of THE CHARACTER and admitting the sculpt is a blatent miss.
But the ones that double down saying they "clearly see SLJ" in the sculpt are absolutely the ones you're referring to imo.
I want both, personally. The character AND the actor playing them. Why I still don't own a single Obi-Wan figure to this day from HT.
Every single one of them are hilariously NOT McGregor's likeness. But Obi-Wan sells, don't require it.
I mean, you are not wrong BUT which figure is not a good representation of the character? I mean, for that you only need to use the same clothes and accesories... that the bare minimum. By that logic I could take a Ken doll figure, dress it in a brown tunic give a purple stick and it would be a fine "representation" of Mace, wouldn't?