A Question if you will

[316what]

I noticed that The Hobbit thread was closed.

Why is this section for movies/TV shows EXCEPT LOTR and Star Wars?

If that's the case, why aren't the Marvel movies in the Marvel section?

Why aren't the DC movies in the DC section?

Why aren't the Horror movies in the Horror section?

Why isn't this section retitled Movies & TV Show discussion EXCEPT LOTR and Star Wars?

This decision makes ZERO sense. People come to this particular forum to discuss ALL Movies & TV Shows. It's easier to find movie threads on LOTR and Star Wars HERE instead of searching through pages of LOTR and Star Wars threads just to find the ONE thread in those sections about the particular movie.

 

[The Josh]

Its been that way for a very long time and there is no need to change it. Finding The Hobbit thread in the LOTR section is quite easy as its near the top of the first page. After the talk by most folks is long gone it will sink off like it would here.

 

[wofford29]

All should be in the movie section.

 

[Boba Ben]

'cause Stone Cold Khev says so.

 

[316what]

'cause Stone Cold Khev says so.

WHAT??!!!!!!

 

[The Ween]

I noticed that The Hobbit thread was closed.

Why is this section for movies/TV shows EXCEPT LOTR and Star Wars?

If that's the case, why aren't the Marvel movies in the Marvel section?

Why aren't the DC movies in the DC section?

Why aren't the Horror movies in the Horror section?

Why isn't this section retitled Movies & TV Show discussion EXCEPT LOTR and Star Wars?

This decision makes ZERO sense. People come to this particular forum to discuss ALL Movies & TV Shows. It's easier to find movie threads on LOTR and Star Wars HERE instead of searching through pages of LOTR and Star Wars threads just to find the ONE thread in those sections about the particular movie.

I agree.....then all should be in their own sections if this is the case. I rarely go into the Star Wars section or Marvel sections because day be crazee!

 

[Boba Ben]

WHAT??!!!!!!

The mod, Khev. He closed the thread and my nickname for him is Stone Cold Khev from now on.

 

[The Josh]

I agree.....then all should be in their own sections if this is the case. I rarely go into the Star Wars section or Marvel sections because day be crazee!

As, I said its always been this way and there is never a problem. Once in a while you get a thread like this by someone and it goes away. Its not a big deal that The Hobbit movie thread is in the LOTR section.

 

[The Entity]

All should be in the movie section.

Agreed.

 

[Moonloop]

All should be in the movie section.

I also agree.

 

[EVILFACE]

Its been that way for a very long time and there is no need to change it.

lol, that isn't a answer to his question.

All movie threads should be in the movie section.

 

[IronFingaz]

Because LOTR fan's think they're better then everybody else. Also more mature

 

[The Josh]

Yes, it is. The Hobbit movie thread in the LOTR section is staying put unless Dave says move it. No need to change the way things have been for years IMO.

 

[Deckard]

Because LOTR fans living in the fantasy world they do, couldn't handle someone saying something remotely not positive or worshiping it as the second coming. Thus if it's in the LOTR section, theres never a chance anything but a fan will see it/post there.

 

[316what]

The mod, Khev. He closed the thread and my nickname for him is Stone Cold Khev from now on.

I guess you missed my joke.

No need to change the way things have been for years IMO.

No matter what the question is, this is historically the worst answer EVER.

 

[DFanatic]

Agreed with the comments above. Movie threads belong here, in the movies forum (what a crazy concept). Can someone start another thread already?

No matter what the question is, this is historically the worst answer EVER.

Whenever I hear someone say that all I hear is "I'm simply terrified of change". That appears to be the case here.

 

[Boba Ben]

I guess you missed my joke.

Oh yeah. Forgot about when he started with the "What?"

[ame]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1UQ2ho7DHMk[/ame]

 

[karamazov80]

Star Wars movie threads go in the Star Wars section, do they not? And folks don't seem to mind that. Maybe Dave feels the franchise-specific sections should trump the "movie" catch-all section for those types of threads. I don't really care, but would prefer it if it were systematic across the board so I would know where to look most of the time I was searching for something.

 

[Deckard]

Guess you better get on moving the Avengers, Spiderman, Ghost Rider, Dark Knight, Batman Vs Superman, Man of Steel, Indy on Blu Ray, and Prometheus threads to their existing sections then huh?

 

[Boba Ben]

This is the headline for the Star Wars and Lord of the Rings forums. No mention of film discussion. If I were new to the forum, I'd think the sections were for collectible discussion only. But I'm not Dave so they can have the movie discussion for those franchises wherever The Dave wants em.

Lord of the Rings Anything and everything pertaining to Lord of the Rings items - Premium Format, 1/6 figures, statues, busts, props , etc. Discussion of other manufactuers such as United Cutlery, Master Replicas, Noble Collection, ToyBiz, etc. is allowed.

Star Wars Anything and everything pertaining to Star Wars items - both from Sideshow and other manufacturers.