"There’s this thing that’s gonna happen that's gonna upset a lot of people, it upset us too. When we signed on for the job, the decision had already been made,” said Cox. "I'm still not convinced it's the right thing to do. But we have to come back big and bold…we’ve got to make a statement after all these years away, and what it does do is it's a wonderful catalyst for the rest of the story.”
At this point, the hints almost seem too obvious, especially if you’ve been following along with production. It’s Foggy. It has to be the death of Foggy Nelson. Why?
Implying this was a decision made in the script stage before they even returned goes back to early reporting that the first, aborted version of the show had Karen Page and Foggy Nelson killed offscreen, driving Matt’s story forward to there (into what was mostly supposed to be a courtroom drama). But if some aspect of that stuck around, the idea is that this is still happening, but maybe onscreen. And likely just Foggy.
We could be guessing if this could be Karen, but unless Deborah Ann Woll is just flat-out lying,
she will be returning for season 2: “I am deeply honored to be a part of the storyline that Dario [Scardapane