Re: DC Collectibles doing Batman The Animated Series figures!!!!!
I'll give you Creeper, Batman, Penguin, and Catwoman, but as much as I dislike the DCC Joker sculpt...
View attachment 311703
View attachment 311704
I appreciate all the feedback, guys, even if it's mocking my opinions a bit.
I won't deny that the DC Collectibles figures have much better detail and paint and I'm a little biased due to nostalgia. At the same time, I do think some of these new figures get less criticism than they deserve. My biggest problem with figures like Joker and Penguin is proportion. Look how small and narrow Joker's eyes are proportionate to his face. There's much more space compared to the Kenner figures due to a massive leap in size, yet they don't use enough of his face for those eyes. I always remember Joker having huge, expressive eyes on the show, whereas in this figure they're almost...beady. I think his eyes look less undersized on the old figure.
I still think Kenner Joker looks cooler and while he may not be as technically accurate and detailed as the DC Collectibles one, he captures the character's
spirit more. And that new Penguin is a disaster. I know he's a tricky design to capture in action figure form due to being an odd forcing of Tim Burton's design into the animated series aesthetic. Still, in my opinion, old Kenner Penguin gets much closer to it.
The new Catwoman design is disappointing because she looks so mannequin-like, especially compared to great female figures like Roxy and Zatanna, who each beautifully re-create an attractive character's distinct personality and facial features with gorgeous accuracy.
Don't me wrong, I don't hate this line. I just have high expectations for it, because when its products are good, they're some of the greatest action figures I've ever seen. I know the sculptors have potential to create superlative work like Roxy, Zatanna, Mad Hatter, and The Riddler, which are a dream come true for me as someone who loves
"Batman: The Animated Series" more than any other show and is really picky about detail/accuracy in action figure facial sculpts. Knowing they can make figures like those just makes it a baffling let down when I see something like their Joker, Penguin, or New Batman Adventures Scarecrow.
Obviously the Kenner Joker and Penguin were light years away from being perfect translations of the original designs. I still think, given their limited resources (compared to today), Kenner sculptors did a better job of translating those character designs to plastic with some accuracy. Same goes for Mattel's New Batman Adventures Scarecrow, maybe their finest achievement.
Captain Clown: Kudos on the Larry David GIF, by the way. If I'm going to get my opinion criticized, I'm glad it's at least with reference to another show I like. I'm grateful for all the love Combat Belt Batman is getting too. It may be my favourite action figure ever, influenced by nostalgia, of course.