Again, no offense intended, but we go through this every time a popular character is recast. I already used the Batman example, but going back even before that, I'm old enough to remember when people said nobody would go see a Spider-Man movie without Tobey Maguire. And then after that nobody would go see a Spider-Man movie without Andrew Garfield.
I'm not even defending the decision here. I think Henry coming back after all this time for a single cameo, just to be fired again, was ******. I just think it's a bit silly to pretend audiences won't go see new Superman movie if it looks good just because Henry's not in the suit. By the time it comes out it'll have been what, at least 12 years since Man of Steel? And around 8 or 9 since Henry's last major theatrical appearance in the Justice League movie.
The fact is that a large audience is already preferring not to watch a DC movie, just look at the box office. The general public does not know or can differentiate the
Batman\Joker universes from the
Black Adam\Shazam universe,
THEY THINK IT IS THE SAME UNIVERSE.
The main problem with using the same characters across multiple movie universes is keeping the same character traits.
Patisson's Batman could be a younger
Batffleck.
Matt Reeves could had a whole trilogy without
Joker to not mess with
Todd's Joker but he insisted in insert the Joker for a cameo, to the main audiences had to know 3 jokers from movies (
Leto, Phoenix and Keoghan) and a lot more from tv series(
Gotham, Titans), THIS WAS HAMADA WORST DECISION AND HIS DOWNFALL.
He fragmented the dc characters and now people are tired of them as a whole, we dont even know who was playing Superman until october.
The difference between the Spider-Man situation is that we had 3 main Spider-Mans in 22 years, but each one was given his time and vision (Garfield less than the other two), but we had a certain thing, in DC everything is a mess and Gunn will be starting from scratch again just as people are getting tired of superheroes.
The Batman is like
Pinocchio's Del Toro, a beautiful film, but with a story that we already have seen multiple times with nothing new.
This is not a normal recast, it's a whole
REMAKE, and with things we already have seen, year one stuff, origin story, naive super-hero.
Gunn is doing exaclty what Reeves did with
year 2 Batman(something
Nolan already had done) with characters and motivations that we already had seem(
Schumacher's Batman Forever).