Of the the three live action films this is the one that actually feels like comic book Hellboy, rather than del Toro lifting the character and doing his own thing with him.
On the 2019 movie in Mignola's own words:
https://www.vulture.com/2019/04/mike-mignola-hellboy-neil-marshall.html
I discovered Hellboy through del Toro's film, and was then inspired to read the comics and novels. I realised that Perlman, aside from the superficial appearance, wasn't really comic book Hellboy, but rather a different entity: movie Hellboy.
With Marshall's film, Harbour isn't as an aesthetically pleasing as Perlman's version, but he and his world
do feel more like the books. It bridges the gap far more closely.
Besides, I'd far rather re-watch this film numerous times than be forced to sit through some other efforts from 2019 which gained higher praise, such as the dreary
Taxi Driver remake,
Joker, or the incredibly tedious
John Wick 3.
Marshall's film just gives the impression that there was so much they wanted to show, but with little chance of being awarded a trilogy to tell it they were compelled to compress it into one.