- Joined
- Apr 25, 2015
- Messages
- 15,177
- Reaction score
- 4,144
I agree. Must be one more JL figure this week surely.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
sigh... I'll admit that I'm interested in a Snyder Director's cut too, but not because I thought Batman v Superman was anywhere close to being one of the best superhero movies of all time. Mostly I think Justice League felt incongruent with what came before it, like the other movies didn't matter. Even though I thought there were huge problems with BvS and Man of Steel, I was hoping that the few good things about them could lead to a pay off in Justice League. It didn't. The timing of the tone shift trying to lighten things up didn't make sense, and the backing away from moving toward an epic encounter with Darksied is disappointing. They probably thought the problem with BvS was "tone" when the problem was the ridiculous story hinging on ridiculous character motivations (Martha!!!! Why did you say that name????). I can not understand why anyone can brag about the merits of "BVS on a literary level". The nonsensical reason for Superman and Batman to fight only looked vaguely intelligent when you compare it to the absurd reason they stopped fighting and became besties. Zack Snynder is an amazing visual director. Looking at the images he puts to the screen is like flipping through a comic and falling in love with the best comic art ever.... just don't read the story. It's not that it didn't have some good moments, the BvS director's cut helped but hardly fixed the primary problems at the core of a really ill conceived and convoluted plot. Joss Whedon's version of Justice League however "corrected" this by giving us an over simplistic ABC story with no real gravitas or weight to it. When you try an turn what should be a climax of a series into a pivot of course the audience will be underwhelmed. So, despite my issues with Snyder, I would love to have seen what I am sure would have been and actual climax to the over all story he has told so far. Love or hate what Snyder has done in the DCEU, getting a complete and congruent series is better than getting a directionless mess where the studio isn't sure what they should do. Ultimately I think the issue with DC movies rests with Warner Brothers. Both Zack Snyder and Joss Whedon are capable directors with strengths and weaknesses and it really is up to the studios to know what they want, understand what they are getting with the director they chose, and know how and when it is appropriate to step in when they need to and how and when to get out of the way when they need to. Warner Brothers has no clue what they are doing, and they are just reacting to what they think the audience wants rather than have a real vision for how they want the DC movies to play out.
As for Wonder Woman, I will agree that the last "boss fight" was a bit weak, but the story itself, the character's journey was fantastic. Anyone who has read Joseph Campbell will see all the classic markers of a "heroes journey" in literature and mythology. Wonder Woman is one of my all time favorite Superhero movies because it hits all the beats in the same way the classic Christopher Reeve Superman film did back in the day. Wonder Woman told a great story because it understood that "heroes" in literature, like those of Greek myths (how appropriate for Wonder Woman in particular) parallel the story of our universal human condition and experience. I think that's why the movie was so well received.
As for the idea that movies without an R rating are "watering down" the stories and characters of comics I will never understand this false equivalency with violence and something being "good" or "deep" or "literary". I'm fine with a rated R superhero movie when the story justifies it. But just making something "rated R" doesn't automatically mean its good either. Logan was fantastic and it was violent, but had a great story and provided commentary on the problem with violence (through wonderfully borrowed themes from the movie Shane). Yes, Wolverine fanboys have been screaming for more blood in Wolverine movies for a long time, and I am sure just the visuals even without the good story would please many of these immature fans if that's what we got, but we actually got a great story too which justified the violence by telling a meaningful story about having to live in a tragic violent world.
That was the funniest sentence I have ever read.BVS has an amazing, well structured story that deconstructs the genre, the characters...
and does an excellent job in exploring the human condition and themes of moral ambiguity and moral subjectivity. The tendency of looking for simple answers in a complex world which is very relevant today. It doesn't hold the viewer's hands as much compared to your typical comic adaption, but it's characters and their motivations are excellently rendered.
It's fairly art house in it's approach.
As a nexus for setting up the necessity of the Justice League and the greater DC film universe it's an amazing literary accomplishment.
Yeah... again not sure it did. Why did the world (or even part of the world) mourn Superman? I like the idea that the world would be conflicted about the existence of Superman, but they never made the case between MoS and BvS for him to contrast the fear of him. Any feelings of the "goodness" of Superman we bring with us out of our familiarity with the character over all, but it's never shown on film for THIS Superman. So the weight of losing Superman isn't really there, though the movie TELLS you its there. The same is true with Batman who made a 180 when it comes to his position on Superman, what really and realistically changed his mind so that he now wants to put a team together in honor of Superman? Again, I get what they were trying to do, but I am not giving them credit for trying when they arn't actually able to do it.For something so thematically rich, it manages to bring everything together really well in the end.
Sadly this is true, and they ate through a bunch of wonderful comic material (like Millers Dark Knight, and the Death and Return of Superman) that it will be a long long time if ever until we can get a decent adaptation or interpretation of those things on film again. It's a lost opportunity.It is a film that admittedly could only be done once.
If only Justice League could have been the counter point to BVS that we deserve.
I'm personally a fan of the current DCEU and like the universe they have set up better than the MCU, but what I don't like is exactly what Jaymas described regarding WB and them seemingly having knee jerk reactions to what they think the fans, people and critics want to see. If the directors they hire have a vision with a particular character that WB initially approved of, I think they're best just staying on track and not pandering to critics, and finishing that vision through.
I want to see it succeed and I want to see it last and go on to rival the MCU, but I just don't see it happening and it bums me out.
I agree. Must be one more JL figure this week surely.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Food for thought if that were the case: if those same critics and fanboys who slammed MoS and BvS because they were pissed for both not being the way they wanted it to be, why is their seemingly main reason now to be pissed off with JL is that it's "inconsistent" because it's not like the previous installments?
Seems to me like they may be a little inconsistent with their criticisms.
Hot Toys needs to step up and produce a new sculpt. Supes needs a smirk. And has anyone else noticed another difference in appearance? It took me a while.
View attachment 381027
Hot Toys needs to step up and produce a new sculpt. Supes needs a smirk. And has anyone else noticed another difference in appearance? It took me a while.
View attachment 381027
Makes perfect sense. MoS and BvS weren’t good, and JL doubles down on the same tone while also trying to be comedic. It’s not saying the previous ones were good, just that it doesn’t make sense to only partially move on. I would have preferred a consistently bad JL than the horrible mess we got.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Sounds damned if you do, damned if you don't to me.
Sounds damned if you do, damned if you don't to me.
Enter your email address to join: