I think it was all about expectations right from the get-go. It is Hot Toys after all - the gold standard.
Out of the box, it's the best 1/6 Indy ever, no debating that, and a decent value for money. Does it look like HF the way the new Sparrow looks like Depp? Of course not. Is it 100% costume accurate the way Depp's costume appears to be? Not quite, but it's A+ quality.
Anyone that calls this inferior junk is a wrong, but anyone that says this release is up there with the best HT is capable of delivering is also wrong.
It's a solid tweener that is better for people who, in one purchase, want a decent, quality Indy figure - but not so great for people who want absolute accuracy in sculpt and outfit (which is quite a few people in this thread.)