This is not a comparrison of players who played decades apart. They at the the same time and 99 was in the league only a few years ( 5 ) before 66 ( 1979 vs 1984 )
I have never once said Lemieux was not great, but THE greatest ever? No, Gretzky is. You could make an argument the even Howe was a better all around player, but I'll give Mary-O the # 2 slot behind Wayne.
Arguing Mario was better is somthing that usually only comes from Pens fans and very few people outside Pens fans ( there are some of course ).
As for Semin scoring 50 goals. If he can keep his attitude in check maybe.
Kit, you're wrong and I am right. On this anyway. hehe
You know, this is an argument that will never be won. You can't convince me 99 is better than 66 and I can't convince you to change your mind.
Semin's attitude seems to be in check. Only guys attitude I am fearful of is Nikolai Zherdev. I got him in a deal with Semin... and all I can say Ken Hitch**** better let him loose. No suffocating his game as he's famously known for doing. He's a defense first... offense second coach. High on the physical and hard on you if you're one dimensional. Thing is Zherdev is a pure offensive player. His skill is with the puck. When he's not on the puck he's useless and he seems too stubborn and immature to play into Hitch's system. Ken is too stubborn to let a young ego inflated Russian get the best of him.
Kit, and anyone else who's hockey savvy, what do you think of my trade?
I get:
Alexander Semin, Nikolai Zherdev, and Patrick Eaves.
I traded off:
Ales Hemsky, J.P. Dumont, and Chris Phillips.
Already had six solid dmen, and Eaves should play on the top 2 lines with the Sens. Especially now that Peter Schaefer was sent packing to Boston. Seems like Heatley and Spezza enjoyed playing with Eaves and like the potential of him sticking on that line. Alfredsson would be better suited on the second line to give two good scoring lines with superstars on each line vs. one super line which was nearly shutout in the Stanley Cup Finals against Anaheim.
Here is what the two top lines in Ottawa could look like:
Heatley-Spezza-Eaves
Vermette-Fisher-Alfredsson
Worse case scenario, if the Senators didn't learn from the Cup Finals that one super line doesn't cut it, a line of Vermette-Fisher-Eaves doesn't look half bad either.
Either way I have a feeling Eaves could get 25-25 to 30-30 in numbers depending which line he lands on. Can't see him getting third line minutes again.