I think there were two cases (that we know of) for Gandalf that were pretty bad that InArt did not feel warranted replacements, if I remember correctly. It’s been awhile so I could be wrong and am prepared to be corrected.
One was paint missing on the nose and instead of replacing the head, they just sent a color pencil to “fix” the missing paint.
Another was someone’s Gandalf head had hair that was about as short as Aragorn’s and InArt said that was acceptable normal variance and not worthy of a replacement.
So, things like that get ppl more worried about if InArt will actually come through with replacements when QC issues like the above, that appear to legitimately fall under real and warranted QC issues, aren’t even address properly by the company.
I’d love to know who those customers were. Where they direct INART store purchasers or were they going through a third party retailer/reseller? I know I’ll be told: “that’s besides the point” and “it doesn’t matter” or really, what people would like to say is that I’m outright stupid. But I’d like to know. I need more information. I’d also like to know how people go about these conversations with who they’re interfacing with. I’m sorry, but I take these things with a grain of salt and what people say online. I also don’t always believe people when they show whatever defect they’re broadcasting. Who knows, what if they damaged the figure themselves, and are outright lying, making it seem like it arrived defective from the factory? Generally speaking, people do it all the time. For various things in life.
I’m aware I’ve said I think some collectors overthink the hobby, and while I don’t think I’d classify myself as I’m “overthinking” this, I just take what people say with a grain of salt lol.
EDIT: I’m not disputing there aren’t QC issues.
I also feel for people who feel worried about potentially getting a defective product. That being said, I think the QC issues topic is overblown.
I also agree that INART needs to streamline their quality management and standardize their QC processes across all factories they send their products through. How I understand it is that Hot Toys has a dedicated and in house factory whereas INART has several factories, so yeah luck of the draw where the figure the end user gets is coming from. Yes, they need to ensure same acceptable range of variation across the board and minimize the range in variance. I’ve never disputed this.
Apologies for my Lousy grammar. I’m watching Monday Night Football lol, and my team is losing so I’m just typing away. Have drinks in me too. Sorry