I've seen a ton of Kyle Reese (atleast 20 at Toys R Us) and checked them all. Some are poorly painted, some are not. T-1000 was like this as well. I saw quite a few Pescadero T-1000 figures that had these sort of "pasty" faces, really bad pale, matte colored faces. Some even lacked eyebrows completely.
The Reese I picked up is perfect. The eyes were impressive, the eyebrows aren't high like that and the 5 o'clock shadow is perfectly painted. Unfortunately, the shot gun is warped from the trigger to the end of the barrel. I was looking for good paint apps and ended up getting a dud gun.
I will admit, for every 2-3 great ones I've seen, I saw even more duds.