A bit late to the question about John, but here are the things I would like to see with the John Figure:
-3 headsculpts : 1 from the first game, 1 with heavy stubble from RDR2, 1 with big beard from RDR2. (Long hair pieces only)
-The Classic Shotgun
-Back Holster from RDR1
-Poncho from RDR1
-Winter Gunslinger Coat from RDR2 (to recreate American Venom)
-John’s Cattleman Revolver
-Micah’s Revolver that you get at the end of RDR2
-Custom Lancaster and Semi-Auto Shotgun
-Rolling Block Rifle
-Fishing Rod
-Squirrel Statue
-Treasure Map or Wanted Poster (or both)
-Binoculars
-Bandolier from RDR1 & Bandit Bandolier from RDR2
-Lasso
-John’s Knife
-Bandana
-Range Gloves
-Tomahawks
-Cigarette
-Dynamite & Ammunition
-Miracle Tonic, Moonshine, Whiskey
That’s all I can think about right now