I agree the movie itself is definitely not as good as AWIL not even close really AWIL is a near cinematic masterpiece if you ask me but with that being said Eddie?s transformation scene in that dark office was quite a sight to behold at that time audiences gasped in fear whereas AWIL was more of a breathtaking sequence meant to showcase the pain and trauma David was experiencing.
So when you break it all down:
Eddie transformation was about a monster revealing himself scaring the audience.
David transformation was about making the audience feel sorry for David.
Both effects hold up quite well I love Eddie?s pointy spider like fingers.
The Snout elongation part of the transformation in The Howling does not hold up while the AWIL version of the appearing Snout has yet to be surpassed.
AWIL has a few awkward looking transformation moments that really have nothing to do with the limitations of the day.. When He looks more like a cave man then a man turning into a wolf.. I always thought it was kind of goofy looking. But its still the best Werewolf transformation IMO.
Its David's performance that makes the scene as classic as it is. I agree with Jye.. you feel sorry for him.
I think AWIL is a perfect film and IS a cinematic Masterpiece. JAWS, AWIL, The Thing, ALIEN, and Halloween. My top 5 horror films have never changed.
I think after JAWS, AWIL may be the film I have seen more times than any other. I was obsessed with that film back in the day.
It has IMO the greatest opening 15 min in all of film. It absolutely perfect. From the Blue Moon opening to the attack on the moors.. Its all perfect.
Jacks death is still the greatest death scene in all of Horror cinema and never gets the credit it deserves.
Wonderful film. I will be watching again soon on 4k blu ray that I paid way to much for.