Like your list and category names...the only things I'd change if I listed 'em is dropping Jedi Luke and Sid/Holochair down to "Impressive" and bumping "Sith Apprentice Darth Vader" up to "Amazing".
Jedi Luke does have the novelty of being first out of the gate, but that slightly dazed expression limits the angles in which he displays well (IMHO) and the Sid/Holo piece is interesting, but like the forthcoming chess table, it's more of an impressive set piece than a figure.
The Sith Apprentice Vader gets a bump up from me because I found it to be such an improvement over the initial Anakin release. The arm was better, the paint app was better and I really appreciate the great detail of the jedi outfit, the gear and the robotic arm. Add to that the really cool stand and he sails to "Amazing" for me....
It's all a matter of taste of course...
And judging from the advance pics we're seeing, Leia/Boussh is going to take her rightful place in the "Amazing" category....