Premium Format Yoda - puppet or CG model?

[FrodoEyes]

Re: SAME

LOL Sir T....I hope I havent offended! It was good, I love Yoda, but I wasn't expecting him to be so....muppety!

 

[Gruson]

Re: SAME

The puppet looks real and not like a CGI cartoon IMO.

However, what the hell were they thinking with Ep1???!? He looked terrible.

 

[Mini Rock]

Re: SAME

You know what'd be really cool, is having OT Yoda as a companion piece for Luke (backpack) and PT Yoda as a companion piece for Sidious (duel). I think this would please fans of both, and at the same time, give us two really good scenes from the movies.

Regarding the silly "which looks more real" debate, both medium's require us to greatly suspend our disbelief in order for us to believe this is a real character, and both do the job well IMO.