Question: When does a "collection" become "clutter"?

Collector Freaks Forum

Help Support Collector Freaks Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
I have a box with every Hasbro cardback I've collected since 1995 when the line started again, and I only do that because before then, there were several times where I wished I had some of the old 12 backs from the first line, and so this way I can always go back and see what the cards were like, plus a lot of them bring back the memory of when I go the figure, which is nice too. The only full boxes I keep are for items that need to be protected in storage or moving and already had good packaging, like GG's foam for all of their items.
 
Yeah I save all the boxes from my various mini busts so that I can move them safely without chipping or cracking the resin.

Most of my 1/6 figures I keep MIB anyway, but most of my mass market toys I open and throw the packaging away.
 
swiftlikessharpthings said:
Bollocks. I forgot all about my LOTR swords I have no room for. Seeing this makes me think it might be time to sell some stuff...
I seriously had the same reaction. Those pics make me want to get rid of more stuff. In fact, I actually asked the guy if he purchases other peoples' SW collections. One man's stored clutter could become another man's "collection". :lol
 
IrishJedi said:
I seriously had the same reaction. Those pics make me want to get rid of more stuff. In fact, I actually asked the guy if he purchases other peoples' SW collections. One man's stored clutter could become another man's "collection". :lol

Did he answer back? I still have some loose POTF2 crap to unload. :rotfl
 
Amanaman said:
Did he answer back? I still have some loose POTF2 crap to unload. :rotfl
No, he didn't. I think he may have thought I was joking. :duh

In related news, my friend Bob ("Vader Painter") and I are starting to organize what might be the world's first all STAR WARS Yard Sale Extravaganza... complete with food, festivities, costumed characters and more. If nothing else, maybe I can finally get rid of a lot of this stuff by offering it to folks for a song. We're also going to donate 20% of whatever we get to Toys For Tots as well as whatever toys are left over afterwards. :monkey3
 
IrishJedi said:
Now, I don't begrudge this fellow for his passion AT ALL. He's a dedicated collector and that's his right. But, whoa:

https://www.therpf.com/showthread.php?t=26807

Seriously, after looking at all of those pics I couldn't help but start questioning this hobby of ours.

That dude is in need of a full life! He needs to become acquainted with this old ball of fire we call the sun.
 
IrishJedi said:
No, he didn't. I think he may have thought I was joking. :duh

In related news, my friend Bob ("Vader Painter") and I are starting to organize what might be the world's first all STAR WARS Yard Sale Extravaganza... complete with food, festivities, costumed characters and more. If nothing else, maybe I can finally get rid of a lot of this stuff by offering it to folks for a song. We're also going to donate 20% of whatever we get to Toys For Tots as well as whatever toys are left over afterwards. :monkey3


Irish, that is a GREAT idea. Please post more info.
 
Darthrazz said:
Irish, that is a GREAT idea. Please post more info.

Well, it will be somewhere in the Atlanta area, of course. We're still trying to decide on the date and time (it will be on a Saturday) and then the location. But there will basically be 3 of us selling off portions of our SW collections at thrift store/yard sale prices and wrapped around that will be what amounts to a "Star Wars Street Party". Like I said, free food (hamburgers, hot dogs, chips, etc) and soft drinks. Star Wars fans meeting and conglomerating. R2 Builders. Members of the 501st and Rebel Legion in costume. A raffle or two. Music. Games. You know the drill.

Once we get things nailed down as far as Date/Time and Location I will post the details here and elsewhere. All are welcome.
 
fool_of_a_took! said:
Definately would'nt want to be turnin' a black light on near that bed.....

Stay away from slave Leia! His stuff is MOMC w/DNA! :rotfl


I won't bother repeating myself on the tastelessness of some of our members. Just please climb your way to a new banana after you're done with your sh#t slinging, simians.


P.S. As for you Took! ... as Shakespeare once put it "The lady doth protest too much, methinks."
 
**Disclaimer**
I write this a fellow board member, and not as a Moderator. These are my own personal opinions.

One theme I find disturbing in this thread is the notion that just because most of his collection is "less expensive" toys, that it is somehow less worthy of collecting and displaying.

Don't jump down my throat, I'm not saying everyone feels this way, but it is definitely a trend in this thread.

There is no right or wrong to collecting! Collecting is a personal thing. People collect everything from old matchbooks to artwork by the "so called" masters, and every one of them has a "collection" they are proud of. Just because some collect "expensive" statues and 1/6 scale figures, doesn't make their collection any better than a collection of Hasbro 3 3/4 inch figures. And just like how everyone has a different collection, we all have different circumstances in life. Some of us are fortunate enough to be able to afford higher priced items and a nice place to display them; some of us may not be so fortunate. And before you come down and say, "if he isn't able to afford a bigger space or more expensive collectibles, then maybe he shouldn't collect", maybe he already collects what he can afford and likes to display his collection. Again, just because he doesn't mind covering the walls, doesn't necessarily mean he has "issues", doesn't have a social life, or needs help. Until you know everything about him and his situation, you are not competent to comment on him; only on your personal taste as to whether you like the collection or not.

This next part is more about the board in general, and not just this thread...
It would behoove us all to step back and reflect on our own situations and stop criticizing everyone around us. If you don't like an item, or a person's collection, or the price they are asking in the buy/sell forums or a new product, then just say, "it's not for me", "I wouldn't buy it", or something similar, and stop make judgmental statements like "that is gay", "he's crazy", "that company is stupid for putting that out", "it's a piece of crap", etc. It only makes you look foolish, childish and immature, and doesn't do anything to further the discussion along. If you have valid arguments about the nature of an item, then state them in an open, honest, and civil discussion. It gets really old to read every other thread and watch it deteriorate into a thread full of insulting posts. Have you noticed a lot of our once "post prolific" board members are all but gone now? There is a very simple reason… disrespect and discourtesy. It’s as simple as that.


This post has been building up for a long time in my mind, and this thread just sort of exemplified every one of the issues I’ve mentioned. I know many of you will say “f you” and move along, and that in itself is sad, but so be it. All I’m asking is for a little more respect and thought before you post… is that too much to ask?
 
lcummins said:
**Disclaimer**
I write this a fellow board member, and not as a Moderator. These are my own personal opinions.

One theme I find disturbing in this thread is the notion that just because most of his collection is "less expensive" toys, that it is somehow less worthy of collecting and displaying.

Don't jump down my throat, I'm not saying everyone feels this way, but it is definitely a trend in this thread.

There is no right or wrong to collecting! Collecting is a personal thing. People collect everything from old matchbooks to artwork by the "so called" masters, and every one of them has a "collection" they are proud of. Just because some collect "expensive" statues and 1/6 scale figures, doesn't make their collection any better than a collection of Hasbro 3 3/4 inch figures. And just like how everyone has a different collection, we all have different circumstances in life. Some of us are fortunate enough to be able to afford higher priced items and a nice place to display them; some of us may not be so fortunate. And before you come down and say, "if he isn't able to afford a bigger space or more expensive collectibles, then maybe he shouldn't collect", maybe he already collects what he can afford and likes to display his collection. Again, just because he doesn't mind covering the walls, doesn't necessarily mean he has "issues", doesn't have a social life, or needs help. Until you know everything about him and his situation, you are not competent to comment on him; only on your personal taste as to whether you like the collection or not.

This next part is more about the board in general, and not just this thread...
It would behoove us all to step back and reflect on our own situations and stop criticizing everyone around us. If you don't like an item, or a person's collection, or the price they are asking in the buy/sell forums or a new product, then just say, "it's not for me", "I wouldn't buy it", or something similar, and stop make judgmental statements like "that is gay", "he's crazy", "that company is stupid for putting that out", "it's a piece of crap", etc. It only makes you look foolish, childish and immature, and doesn't do anything to further the discussion along. If you have valid arguments about the nature of an item, then state them in an open, honest, and civil discussion. It gets really old to read every other thread and watch it deteriorate into a thread full of insulting posts. Have you noticed a lot of our once "post prolific" board members are all but gone now? There is a very simple reason… disrespect and discourtesy. It’s as simple as that.


This post has been building up for a long time in my mind, and this thread just sort of exemplified every one of the issues I’ve mentioned. I know many of you will say “f you” and move along, and that in itself is sad, but so be it. All I’m asking is for a little more respect and thought before you post… is that too much to ask?


Great post Lonnie! You and I have talked many a time over stuff just like this and we both feel the same way. :duff
 
lcummins said:
This next part is more about the board in general, and not just this thread...
It would behoove us all to step back and reflect on our own situations and stop criticizing everyone around us. If you don't like an item, or a person's collection, or the price they are asking in the buy/sell forums or a new product, then just say, "it's not for me", "I wouldn't buy it", or something similar, and stop make judgmental statements like "that is gay", "he's crazy", "that company is stupid for putting that out", "it's a piece of crap", etc. It only makes you look foolish, childish and immature, and doesn't do anything to further the discussion along. If you have valid arguments about the nature of an item, then state them in an open, honest, and civil discussion. It gets really old to read every other thread and watch it deteriorate into a thread full of insulting posts. Have you noticed a lot of our once "post prolific" board members are all but gone now? There is a very simple reason… disrespect and discourtesy. It’s as simple as that.[/COLOR][/COLOR]

This post has been building up for a long time in my mind, and this thread just sort of exemplified every one of the issues I’ve mentioned. I know many of you will say “f you” and move along, and that in itself is sad, but so be it. All I’m asking is for a little more respect and thought before you post… is that too much to ask?


In a perfect world that would be an ideal scenario, but there are some major a-holes lurking on this board and you're never going to change their obnoxious ways. :(
 
Brent72 said:
In a perfect world that would be an ideal scenario, but there are some major a-holes lurking on this board and you're never going to change their obnoxious ways. :(

Only too true... but if even one or two stop and think about their posts, it will be one step closer...
 
Nicely put, Lonnie. Unfortunately, there are those who feel it's their right to post whatever they want. There are some threads (threads I have interest in) I don't even bother reading anymore because of the constant negativity. It's tiresome and takes the fun out of it.
 
As the creator of this thread, I certainly hope none of that is directed toward me. I didn't set out to trash this guy myself, but just wanted to raise what I feel are some valid questions regarding this hobby of ours.
 
I gotta chime in here.

1) Collecting is an individual, personal issue/experience. Collect what you like. Have fun. You can collect garbage or used scabs... but as long as it makes you happy - good for you! You can display things in glass cases, carboard boxes or on your back lawn... as long as it makes you happy - good for you!

Basically, as long as your collecting isn't impeding you from leading a "healthy" life (i.e getting you fired, divorced, in jail etc.)... it's all good IMHO. I would never judge anyone else's collection. Ever. I have my tastes. They have theirs. The end.

2) There was a panel at C4 about "completists"... and Duncan Jenkins and Gus Lopez hosted it along with the woman that is the archivist for Sansweet's collection. It was an amazing panel. I cannot relate to collecting in that fashion... but I loved how much those guys loved being completists. They even talked about how Duncan would travel Europe and buy every single copy of every Star Wars book in every language he could find. Wow! They would take trips to Mexico for Star Wars ice cream wrappers and pinatas etc. They'd be stoked to find a pair of Star Wars sandals in a discount bin for .99 cents. It made them happy. So for them... I think it's great!
 
I can't help, but wonder if I am thought of as one of the a-holes since I was a little critical of this guys collection. I have usually maintained an even keel around here other than picking at josh once in a while which was done in jest until he finally got offended by me, but seemingly no one elses jokes.

I don't think my collection is any "better" than anyone elses, but I also think that people do notice a difference in higher end pieces and small "toys". I never made any comments that this guy could not afford higher end stuff and I will say that if I bought as many smaller figures as this guy does then I could not afford higher end stuff either as I am FAR from rich so it's not about "who has more money" since he's spent as much in smaller stuff as I have in larger stuff. Maybe it was a little short sighted of me to call his collection "a bunch of $5 toys" so for that I am sorry. To put it hoe Lonnie did "It's not for me".

My main concern about this collection is that this guy has let it take over his entire life and to me that shows that there may be some other type of issues going on. Even his bed sheets were Star Wars. To me there is something a little odd about a grown man with Star Wars bed sheets and covers. He almost seems to be totally hidding away in his collection world.

I could be totally wrong and he may be perfectly well adjusted as an adult, but I can only make a call based on what see and what I see is someone who appears to be a little beyond obsessed.

The "not getting laid" stuff is an obvious "Star wars geek" joke that we have all heard from time to time. If you actually do get laid then I don't see why it should offend anyone at all. We all know it's a joke.

If anyone here takes my joking around seriously and wants to think i am a some big a-hole then so be it. I don't think I am and I do like to joke and ribb people at times, but I can also take it in return w/o getting my panties in a bunch.

That's all I really have to say.

thanks.
 
IrishJedi said:
As the creator of this thread, I certainly hope none of that is directed toward me. I didn't set out to trash this guy myself, but just wanted to raise what I feel are some valid questions regarding this hobby of ours.

No, it was not directed at any one person... just a general trend the thread had followed.

...and to anyone else, again, it was not directed at any one person, just the general feeling the thread (and many like it) had taken.
 
While I am in agreement that it's tactless, classless and unfair to simply throw people like this collector under the bus I do also believe that it's not right to shelter them from being questioned about their possible obsessions, either... especially when it gets to a certain point.

To me, ANYTHING can get past the point of rationality. And while we should be tolerant of others' lifestyles and behaviors there is a reason why things like drugs are illegal. IMHO, collecting to such an extreme is not so indifferent to being addicted to alcohol or a chemical drug. I know... I've been through both.

It could very well be the case that this guy is a happy, successful and functioning member of society. And if so, that's terrific! But it could also be true that he's not and needs help in some areas. I'm not saying that I or anyone else here is in the position to make that determination (and this thread was never meant to question this particular collector, per se)... but there is nothing wrong with pointing out that (even with toys) there ARE lines that can be crossed and if/when people cross them it's symptomatic of larger, life-affecting issues.

Like it or not, there HAVE been people who have lost their jobs, marriages, etc. over this stuff. :(
 
Last edited:
Back
Top