Re: Read Dead Redemption 2 (Fall 2017)
I think it'd be great if a Marston showed up in GTA. Just some bumbling insurance with a gambling addiction who owes money to every crook in town and doesn't even seem like he would be part of that bloodline or something.

I think that's one of the most interesting things about RDR is that Jack isn't a very compelling protagonist, but the thing of it is that I don't think he's intended to be. When he's a kid, he's kind of reserved and bookish. He was never meant to be a Cowboy, whether John wanted it or not.
And I think that's why everybody hates Jack so much. Because he is a pretender. When John wore that hat, it was earned. In blood, in hardship; he was a cowboy through and through because that was his life, and when he dies, that's the final nail in the coffin of the West. You see the industrialist expansion and the dirt roads and small towns being paved over with cities of brick and cobblestone, and you know that this is all coming to an end, but there's a degree of romanticism to the stories of men and women who lived their lives trying to tame the American frontier and while they succeeded and progress was the victor in all of this, you could argue that their hardship defined their experiences and, in creating a world free of that, they paved the way for mundanity.
At the same time, if you were to ask these people who had to face outlaws, natives, dysentery, tuberculosis, wild animals, and all manner of things trying to kill you, I'm pretty sure most of them would trade it for a job in tech support with full benefits any day of the week.
