Metaphorge, payment received, thanks
Yes, the movie is different from the comic but not in any significant way that takes away from the story. I got into the comic when it first came out and always loved it. I think I was around 17 at the time, and it was one of the first comics I'd read (apart from old horror comics) that told a real story and didn't deal with super heroes. As comics go, I was amazed by that aspect.
Eric had no last name in the comic, and he was not a musician. He was an auto mechanic. He and Shelly did not live in the inner city; they had recently purchased a house in the country they were renovating. The villian names are all turned around, though they pretty much nailed the look of each one. In the comic, Tin Tin was actually Top Dollar. They were just a very low-level gang of typical street thugs, not the hired henchmen of an organized crime outfit, not part of any heirarchy. And if I recall, Sarah had no mother that was ever shown and Sarah's name was Darla; the name given to her mother in the movie. The charcter also had a VERY small role compared to the film. She was just a street kid Eric met AFTER he came back.
There were differences in the details, but nothing that took away from the story or its message. I don't think the skull cowboy would have worked in the movie. When it came to Eric's resurrection the comic spent more time focusing on the "how", the movie focused completely on the "why". The skull cowboy was part of the "how".
Yes, the ending was weak. Albrecht and Eric had a clear line drawn down the middle of their relationship, and they crossed it. It would be like seeing SPAWN team up with Sam and Twitch and swapping jokes. It had a "Lethal Weapon" feel that didn't fit the rest of the film.
Even so, I can't imagine anyone labeling this movie as cheesy or anything. It's a great story. It works on a similar level as Star Wars in that it deals with very deep-rooted aspects of human emotion; fundamental things we can all easily identify with. But as was already said, "To each their own". I've seen people fall head-over-heels in love with stuff that I personally feel is totally unwatchable
The second Crow was really good, too. But I don't like it as much as I used to. My youngest son turns 6 tomorrow, about the age of the little boy in that movie, so I find that one to be unwatchable. But not because it's a bad movie. Though it's funny to see Thomas Jane in drag.