I have a boatload of carded McFarlane toys I need to get rid of just to make room for all my 1/6 stuff now. Austin Powers, Movie Maniacs, tortured souls, etc. I have a feeling this stuff is also worth a fraction of what I paid for it new
The main issue with the fall of McFarlane is mainly:
1.They overproduced as normal retail runs that's available everywhere
2.Small % of the fans are actual Spawn fans while majority got hooked because of the beyond their time sculpts & paint, of course a % are just following bandwagons whom now have moved on to better stuffs.
3.They created way too many figures & variants of the figures & series discouraging folks from collecting them all.
4.They take up more space than 3.75" figures like Star Wars, so people want to ged rid of them for newer stuffs.
5.They smell & the chains rust.
IMO even to date some of their figures mainly statue figures still look superb, they are just like PVC of current statues with some articulations. However not everyone's a fan of monsters & scary characters, so they lose out to even the worst Ironman figures, and they don't have a long running fans like Star Wars or Batman to be diehard fans.
The market really doesn't do justice to those good Spawn figures. If McFarlane were a Japanese company, i bet today everyone would still be hunting them at high price like those Vintage G1 Transformers.
Don't forget McFarlane was the pioneer in pushing for high quality sculpt & paint at the cost of less articulations which was later adopted into the industry, which has now moved on to Super Articulation figures that inherited good sculp & paint, but still they don't look as great as semi/non articulated of course.
Hard to believe figures like Overkill Deluxe selling for few bucks. That guy has great sculpt & paint quality, and sheer size. Beats any G.I Joe figures out there.