Superman (July 11th, 2025)

[Wor-Gar]

I saw the short version of the trailer on SNL and it showed all the Krypto stuff but not Lois. Weird. Not a good version. My wife was wholly unmoved. Just said "where's Cavill?"

 

[pixletwin]

Please stay on topic folks. Snyder has more than one thread dedicated to his works.

 

[jye4ever]

Batman has serious control issues.

Trying to repair something that can’t be repaired.

Superman does not, the guy can swim in lava.

Do not give Superman the same psychological problems as Batman.

 

[Wor-Gar]

Ledger Joker basically gave Batman the old Gene Hackman/Lex Luthor Double-Jeopardy "you can't save both" challenge -- that's always a good stress-test on Superman. There's very little to challenge a true Superman with, psychologically. He shouldn't be so ego-based that he may give up helping people if they throw cans at his head. Isn't he above that? Doesn't he realize that humans are bad and good -- the point being, he has to rise to inspire our better angels? It's the reason I don't like Superman -- he can't really be bad and still be Superman. His "mistakes" come only from him not being 'super' enough, being weakened by kryptonite or being given a double-jeopardy challenge he can't win. He's the boy scout. He's Captain America. He must always be in the good. You 'break' Superman when you break his spirit... but we all know that truly can never be broken.

Can Superman ever really be a true 3-dimensional character?

 

[ZE_501]

Can Superman ever really be a true 3-dimensional character?

I think so. He still has relationships and no doubt they carry a certain baggage given his secret and his power.

And then there's the brutal reality that for all of his power he can't save everyone, all the time. How does he grapple with that?

Besides -- Superman eventually became a DC demigod but in the beginning he couldn't even fly, if I'm remembering right.

You can write his powers anyway you want. Make him unbelievably fast and durable, sure ... but you *could* still build in some kind of limit. If you wanted to.

I think maybe that's what He Who Shall Not Be Named tried to do but it went too dark.

Then there's the idea that in a Superhero story we take certain unbelievable premises as axiomatic. So there's always good old suspension of disbelief in terms of the more thorny nuances, if the broad strokes of the story are entertaining and engaging enough.

 

[Cap'n Cook]

Please stay on topic folks. Snyder has more than one thread dedicated to his works.

Finally.

 

[The Clown Prince of Crime]

I saw the short version of the trailer on SNL and it showed all the Krypto stuff but not Lois. Weird. Not a good version. My wife was wholly unmoved. Just said "where's Cavill?"

You should have said, "He's home washing his tights! Hahahaha!"

 

[jye4ever]

 

[xb24]

The CW-like trailer vs. the cinematic trailer:

 

[ironwez20]

View attachment 745464

Superman has a big draw still. If I remember correctly man of steel had a huge viewer count when the trailer dropped.

 

[Wor-Gar]

I'm pretty sure, despite that look, I will care more about Gunn's Superman and Lois than I ever did for Snyder's.

 

[ZE_501]

I'm pretty sure, despite that look, I will care more about Gunn's Superman and Lois than I ever did for Snyder's.

Brosnahan can *act*. She has a lot of range and she's much more than just a pretty face. Amy Adams is no slouch but while I *accepted* her as Lois I didn't *believe* in her as Lois. I think Brosnahan is going to kill it, the way she can cycle from manic wisecracking to incredible depth.

As for our new Supes ... someone here pointed out that Cavill (and don't get me wrong, I think he made a great looking Superman) doesn't look *wholesome* and while I never thought of it that way, I have to agree. The new guy is more believable to me off the hop because he seems to carry an innocence around with him.

This is all based off a couple minutes of footage so I'm not married to any of it ... just some first impressions.