Just started binging this. Gotta get through 7 and 8.
Overall, props for making S2 a whole lot better. The actors including Galadriel put their backs into it; so kudos for that. IMO the natural environments and design work, costumes etc. are all upgrades.
I'd even rewatch S2. So good job Amazon.
Not gonna say I don't cringe at the Tolkien memba berries and scenes that rip off both LOTR and the Hobbit. There's not much Tolkien here as opposed to being really expensive fan fiction. So much cringe including the giant gumball machine rings, making so much focus on RINGS, everything is about these RINGS and Celebrimbor WTF...tho hafta say Vicker's Sauron is creepily understated and effective. Huh.
I'll give credit too tho not sure it works - of coming up with reasons Celebrimbor behaves the way he does and tying that to Sauron being able to shapeshift reality as well as himself. Someone was trying when they wrote this.
Then there was the Venom black sludge...so much cringe. But yet, IMO it's pretty watchable too. Some effective grittiness besides the soap opera dramatics. Some IMO good interchanges like Galadriel and Adar. Some good fights including Galadriel. It's like someone read a LOT of Tolkien, threw it in a blender, and then dumped it out and spent millions on fan fiction. But I can see where the money went this season.
IMO this does not suck. Some stuff does like orc babies, but a fair amount doesn't. If you turn off the Jackson films, S2 is a reasonable story that has some good moments and is worth a watch.