Which is better?: Constantine (2005) or John Carter (2012)

[Alatar]

Both movies fall under the category of flawed and certainly not as popular as the studio hoped. But they both have a following of sorts. Maybe not enough of a following to call them cult films. But whenever I see either film mentioned I notice some folks saying they really like the movie.

So I’m putting them into the octagon as gladiators for a cage match. Which is better?

Or which do you like more?

And what other films like this can you think of?