Wow Vader AL you are a necroposter and a thread killer all wrapped into one aren't you. Ironically I just received one today so I'll give you some advice.
Well to answer your question you'll have to answer some questions:
1) Have you found one at a good price? Even with this question a "good price" is relative. For me about the price of a SW PF was fair. If you pay more than that you will probably feel a little cheated and some will feel cheated at that price so read on.
2) Do you want "the best" 1:1 yoda and have the money for it? Most will say the Gentle Giant one is the best and I agree(depends on which style Yoda you want though). While I agree it's the best I don't want to drop 1k on it so I chose this one over the SS Yoda bust because I wanted a full bodied yoda but I will pick that one up one day too. Of the three this one is the lowest quality.
3) Did you refuse to buy the SS Boba Fett PF because it was hollow? If you answered "yes" then this one isn't for you because it is hollow and light for the size.
4) Do you stare at your collectibles and look for paint flaws? If yes then this one isn't for you because there are parts where the paint bleeds over a little if you look at them up close.
5) Do you want an accurate sized yoda? if so then this one has that going for it. The GG one is too tall but I'd still take the GG yoda in a heartbeat if I could find one for $500 or so but this one is accurate so that is a plus.
I will say, for me, I am really happy with this piece because I like the sculpt(although the feet are weak) and the overall paint-app and well, it's a 1:1 yoda. I plan on pulling his hair out because when you look closely at his head it looks like he has hair-plugs and will re-apply the hair so it looks correct. I also want to cut the lightsaber out of his hand and insert a MR lightsaber. I'll have to destroy the one in his hand but it won't feel complete to me without having the MR one in his hand. This yoda combines the older yoda with a lightsaber and that will turn some off because they either like the old yoda or the one in EP 2 when he battles Dooku and not a mixture of the 2.
Here's some pics, hope I helped.