Just got back from post office after speaking to a manager. I explained the bizarre situation. She logged into her computer to check the details. It was my regular mail carrier that delivered the package. No doubt in my mind that this guy delivered it to my house. He knows who I am on a first name basis and even tries to deliver packages before 7:00 since he knows I work typical 9-5 job. Delivery for this particular package was made around 11:15 in afternoon. So someone, most likely a kid walking home from school, took package off my front steps, opened it, and then either got caught by parents or felt guilty, and just left it by the mailbox.
I asked if there was anything I could do to prevent future occurrences, since this thief is now probably aware I have cool pop culture statues delivered to my house. USPS doesn't have anything to do that formally, but since I went in and complained, the manager is going to speak to the mail carrier about it and I'm going to leave a letter in the mail box asking him not to leave packages by the front door any longer. Manager lady said they have option not to leave it at front door if there have been reports of packages dissapearing from certain "bad" neighborhoods. So while it will inconvenience me, I'm not wanting to go through this again.
Then I explained that this was a collectible statue and when the packaging is torn up, it decreases the value of the item. So could I get a partial refund on insurance because of what happened? Insurance only applies as follows:
1) if damaged, surrender the item to them, they will review your claim, and then offer a refund (partial or full).
2) if the item is damaged but can be repaired, you must provide two separate bids for cost of repair. They will honor the lower bid. Once you can provide a receipt of the repaired work, the insurance will cover that amount, up to the insured amount.
So basically I'm screwed. I don't think I can get an honest "repair" bid on this box, let alone two of them.
It could have been worse, so I guess I'll just have to chalk this up to crappy luck.
Oh yeah, delivering at work isn't an option for me. I work where you need a badge to get in and there are several hundred people in my building, and there are multiple buildings. I don't think the security guards would like to be nominated as my sideshow collectibles courier, plus I wouldn't trust them all that much either.