In my opinion, those two figures look different enough that it will be like comparing apples to oranges. Thus, I suggest that you decide what matters the most to you. I'll give you some examples below.
Cap Pros:
- I like Cap's bearded and rugged look with the rolled up sleeves. His look in IW is also unique compared to previous Cap releases.
- I like the Black Order spears that you get with the Movie Promo version.
- Cap is one of my favorite characters.
- This release of Cap has more interesting accessories (for me) compared to Thor.
Cap Cons:
- I prefer a little more color but I understand that it may not go well with his rugged look in IW. Besides, there are other version of Cap with brighter colors.
- The head sculpt is not 100% in my opinion but it still looks good to me. There are not too many figures (that I am aware of) that have a 100% accuracy anyway.
- I prefer his classic shield although the Wakanda shields look cool and interesting if you want something different.
Thor Pros:
- The head sculpt looks good.
- I like his swap out arms because it gives you more display options.
- The light up feature is a plus.
- The cape can also be removed for an additional display option.
Thor Cons:
- I am not a fan of his short haired look and his eye patch. I prefer the longer hair from previous movies.
- I prefer the look of the mjolnir to the axe he got in IW.
I hope this helps. I also suggest watching reviews on YouTube or reading Michael Crawford's review on the Thor figure (link below).
https://www.mwctoys.com/REVIEW-111218a.htm
appreciate the reply thank you
i actually pulled the trigger on Thor last night for a couple reasons.
1. being if we’re comparing movie moments i can’t see anyone with a better scene in IW than Thor. and although i agree with the weapon thing i think down the road this will be one of the more coveted Thors
2. i’ll probably get whatever version of Endgame Captain America they release. judging by the trailer he’s wearing the stealth suit which is my favorite suit i just heard bad things about his Hot Toys figure
so for me Thor now, Cap later seemed to be the right move.
that’s if i don’t cave on a Cap before that lol