Nah, you're way off base.
First off, I'm a "real joe fan" if there ever was one. I'm on Hisstank, Yojoe, Toy News International and the rest. And I love this figure.
Sideshow has never been about slavishly recreating the original figures exactly how they were. I'm not sure why you'd expect to see a teal ninja, when they made more contemporary changes to guys who were already pretty realistic looking, like Duke, Beach Head, and Firefly.The other guys here are right about Hisstank. There's some cool guys on there, no doubt. Most of the regulars. I'd say at least 10-15%. But there are a ton of whiny, cheap complainers too. Guys who just got onboard the whole Joe collecting thing with the 25th line, and will raise all hell about having to pay $20 for a figure on the aftermarket. They sure as heck won't pay Sideshow prices.
Also, a lot of them seem vehemently opposed to anything that isn't 25th style, including the original RAH figures, which I really don't understand at all. I mean, full on HATE o-ring figures.
I prefer MOTUC figures, but I'm certainly not going to hate on the originals. I LOVED those as a kid, and I respect them too, as well as those who collect them.
Don't get me wrong, I like Hisstank for what it is, but using that site as a benchmark for "real fans" (a term I hate, btw) when half of them seem to have a severe hate-on for o-ring RAH figures and more than half seem to complain every time they can't get something for clearance prices. Should have used Yojoe.com or one of the other Joe sites - or better yet, a 12" Joe collector site.