I've never gotten a PF that was in good shape from Sideshow the last 5 that I've gotten directly from them have been bad.
Black Widow- bad paint
Harley Quinn- missing head
Freddy- glue on the hat.
Punisher- broken off ear
Deadpool- cracked paint and concave base
The only piece that I've ever had arrive without problems was the legendary scale black Spider-Man bust. Which was years ago, so . . . Yeah they suck ha.
And Rogue just needs all new heads made completely. I dont care that it's been years later and I don't even care if they charge for them. They just need to show up on the website for $20 a piece. Say "Alternate Rogue head for your Premium Format Figure"
Except for 2 statues for me, SS is mostly good on replacements and credits. But those 2 situations left me feeling not so great towards SS since they really had serious issues.
I've never had a bad one
"Bad" is subjective. Unless you're getting statues not from the same factories the rest of us are receiving from (which could be the case if you get samples, I don't know) out of the many statues you seemingly have there are surely a number of them that others would say are bad and that you're settling. It's your collection so it's ok as long as you're satisfied. I'm not saying you do have any that are bad (plus I notice you tend to skip certain peices), but I do doubt your collection as a whole has no issues that somebody would scrutinize. There's a bit of paint slop for somebody to scrutinize somewhere. And if you get a pristine Apocalypse, please do post pics.