Arnold or Stallone ?

[Saya]

If your talking the ability to act then its- Sly
But if your talkin a great action actor, no talking neccessary-arnold, dude can't act but he can play a machine like no ones business! ummm-Sly for me then..? I guess.

 

[galactiboy]

Arnold... mostly based on rewatchability. While I love Rambo and Rocky I don't need to watch them very often. But Conan, Terminator and to a lesser extent Predator are flicks I like to watch regularly.

 

[raider]

Arnie for me

 

[EVILFACE]

Stallone is the better actor. Schwarzenegger is the better movie star. Both are great action stars and I enjoy those moives.

I give the edge to Arnold.

 

[DinoLast]

I will go for Arnie because I have not only enjoyed his action movies ,but some of his comedies as well like Kindergarten Cop and Twins.
I must have taken about 10 mins to make my mind up on this

 

[pixletwin]

Interesting distinction EF.

I voted Sly. I think his characters have more heart, but after reading Gboy's comment I agree that I tend to rewatch Ahnold films.

 

[galactiboy]

I'd agree that Sly is the better actor as well... although both really play one character, but Sly's does tend to be more convincing.

 

[karamazov80]

Arnold... mostly based on rewatchability. While I love Rambo and Rocky I don't need to watch them very often. But Conan, Terminator and to a lesser extent Predator are flicks I like to watch regularly.

I never thought of it this way, but this is true for me as well. I know a great dramatic performance when I see it (I'm thinking of Day-Lewis in "There Will Be Blood"), but I don't really feel like watching these that often once I have seen them the first time. But movies with great action in them (or comedy, for that matter) will keep me coming back, even if the performances weren't that great.

 

[Rock83]

Total Recall and Jingle all the way is perfect examples why you dont have to be a good actor to make it big.Ive never seen a person that is allowed to act like an Animal in a movie like Arnold,Recall is ALL Noises and grunts,nothing more.
In Running man he is stressed through the entire movie which makes it even funnier when its him.

 

[Rock83]

Arnold... mostly based on rewatchability. While I love Rambo and Rocky I don't need to watch them very often. But Conan, Terminator and to a lesser extent Predator are flicks I like to watch regularly.

While i feel the completely opposite

 

[wofford29]

I went with Arnold, although I think Sly is a much better actor.

 

[Voorhees27]

Total Recall and Jingle all the way is perfect examples why you dont have to be a good actor to make it big.Ive never seen a person that is allowed to act like an Animal in a movie like Arnold,Recall is ALL Noises and grunts,nothing more.
In Running man he is stressed through the entire movie which makes it even funnier when its him.

I almost pissed myelf when I read this, animal?

 

[Rock83]

I almost pissed myelf when I read this, animal?

surprised?Off course youre not

 

[karamazov80]

Total Recall and Jingle all the way is perfect examples why you dont have to be a good actor to make it big.

But if you don't have talent, it doesn't hurt to be a huge muscle bound freak.

 

[Rock83]

But if you don't have talent, it doesn't hurt to be a huge muscle bound freak.

not in the 80`s anyway.

 

[Voorhees27]

I must say that this polls results are very dissapointing. Aside from Terminator 1 & 2 Arnold is just ......................... EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEYYYYYYYYYYYAAAAAAEEEYYYYAAAAAHHEEEYYAHAHHAA!

 

[Cap'n Cook]

Arnie.

My post was considered too short.

 

[Rock83]

I must say that this polls results are very dissapointing. Aside from Terminator 1 & 2 Arnold is just ......................... EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEYYYYYYYYYYYAAAAAAEEEYYYYAAAAAHHEEEYYAHAHHAA!

agree,besides terminator he is just a big clown.Playing a Robot doesnt require alot of skills either

 

[Voorhees27]

agree,besides terminator he is just a big clown.Playing a Robot doesnt require alot of skills either

Well I wasn't 100% serious he did play a cool role in Conan. Although he still overplayed the EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEYAH! noises they worked for that character.

 

[EVILFACE]

Yea, he grunted alot when he was "fighting" the witch.