Got mine tonight and had a little time to put them together.
My general impressions? Really great!
It's an impressive set! And a really great deal for two figures with a fair amount of accessories! (Two hobbits with lots of complicated clothing for the same price as one space raccoon.)
I'm honestly shocked at how much I like them both. Like a lot of us, I've been watching the photos of the sculpts in this thread with some trepidation and disappointment, but ... and I know this is a cliche around these parts ... in hand they don't bother me at all!
Yes, Frodo's face is a little too angular and has too heavy a brow ... he looks a little more like strung-out Frodo from the end of RotK than fresh-faced Frodo from FotR. And yes, the likeness is probably in the 70-80% range. But overall I really dig him!
And Sam ... I'm kind of astonished but ... I actually like the Sam sculpt more than Frodo. Yes, his neck is bizarrely thin, but if you futz his cape correctly, you'll never be able to see it. It takes a while to assemble him, but once you get all the pots and pans threaded onto his backpack (which is kind of a pain -- bring your tweezers), he looks terrific! I don't think they changed anything with the sculpt, but in-hand I'd put the likeness in the 85-90% range. Which REALLY surprised me. Granted, all of this is
entirely subjective and no two collectors seem to agree on this kind of thing, but that's where I'd put him.
The real star of this release is the cut and sew work. The outfits are fantastic. The challenge with LOTR figure costumes has always been all the layers. But despite all the layers, these guys never look bulky. Asmus has chosen fabrics that drape and hang very nicely while keeping them super thin and in scale. Really nice finishing work, too. Mine didn't have a single errant thread that needed trimming. And there are plenty of really nice touches that you probably will never see or notice in your display, like the suspenders, the super tiny buttons, or the intricate (and accurate) tailoring on Frodo's flap-front pants.
Beautiful work all around, Asmus. Thank you!
While Sam has his cooking utensils, I think Frodo's best accessory is the One Ring. (I had to get out my magnifying glass and do a bit of micro-surgery on the chain which had come apart in the box, but I got it sorted and it looks great.) The scale of the ring and chain is really impressive -- it's all real metal, and incredibly fine and delicate. The scale looks perfect.
Overall, I'm really happy with this set. Sure, both likenesses could be better, but this is a really nice set. Fully satisfied. It isn't the big (or even small) step backward we all feared from the initial photos.
I know it's a tired old cliche, but these
really do look better in hand than any of the pictures I've seen.
Anyhow, those are my two cents. Hope everybody else is as happy with them as I am!