I'm amused that you have a series of well-lit photographs, showing the figure's flaws, then you have an overexposed photo which hides the flaws, and people are like "Yes, I much prefer the photo which hides the figure's flaws"
I just marathoned all three special editions. Everyone is fairly familiar with just how much camera work and stunt doubles went into making the actors appear to be the right size for their species.
Additionally, I am fairly convinced that Peter Jackson and the cinematographer were doing a lot of purposeful blocking and lighting to accentuate certain angles and features of both Orlando and Viggo. I think that is part of the problem Asmus is hitting up against when sculpting these two.
There are a lot of scenes where most of Orlando’s acting wholly consists of sucking in his cheeks to accentuate his cheek bones or jutting out his jaw and chin to accentuate his mouth over his forehead. In other scenes the lighting does that work. If you over analyze his look throughout that film, it is really inconsistent.
More of these toy photographers need to imagine they’re Peter Jackson berating Orlando in every shot. “Angle that F’ing chin out. No one wants to see that much forehead, Bloom!”
So I think Asmus has the unenviable task of figuring out what the most “idealized” version of Legolas is and translating that to plastic. They just haven’t hit it yet. Maybe someone can photoshop the detailing of the new mouth, nose, and eyes onto the head shape of the old sculpt?
Sorry for the low rez YouTube pulls. Photo 1 is Bloom sucking his cheeks in as a background character. Photo 2 is one of the rare front shots of him without lighting or face squeezing tricks. 3 and 4 are the same scene as he is talking to Gimli. His face is lit to highlight his cheekbone on one side. He moves from the standard face straight up and down position to jutting his chin far out and tensing up. Photo 4 looks more like “Legolas” to me. His emphasized features are radically different. But they’re both Orlando in the same continuous shot.
I think this tells me the “ideal” Legolas is pretty different from Orlando Bloom. It is some combination of shot at an angle, tilt in the head, tension in the lower half of the face, and lighting on the cheekbones.
Viggo does this stuff too throughout the series but not as much. Bernard Hill and Hugo Weaving aren’t getting manipulated through light and facial contortions like Orlando and Viggo. Their sculpts are pretty spot on. I don‘t envy Asmus this task of creating the ideal Legolas and Aragorn. I do think Legolas is more successful of sculpt and I want to see a good photographer do more to manipulate the angle of the sculpt on the neck joint and frame it with lighting. Because that is exactly how Orlando Bloom was shot.