Hi Linda
I know your plight... I think there is "imperfections" in most of the statues in some way....
Personally i accept some of them.... Some i dont... The other day i had a pin hole in the breast plate of aragorn and chips in the crown.. (hard to see) but i was fine tooth combing it...
I did return the item.....
I can understand frustration as you seem to get a few..
I looked at the last pic and found it hard to find what was wrong.... Again with the "hawk eye" on i see the bust on the right has a small tip of the ear missing....
I can appreciate all sides of the story.... No one is really wrong here. You or sideshow....
As the customer you have the right to be satisfied in your purchase... If the imperfections are not right by you then you return it . Then its up to sideshow to make a judgement call.... I can see if they had sent a few of something and the customer was still not satisfied then they would opt for refund ..... It is unfotunate but how many should be sent....
For the perfectionist i think one would have a hard time getting a complete collection as i believe it is hard to find one "perfect one" with all paint perfect, no chips, cracks , repairs....
for this reason i have accepted some fallacies.... My cave troll has a repaired chain.... (for me a very minor thing and not worth trying to chase a mint one and risk a broken arm )
I have had multiples of some items. I even had armies of Galad archers and Easterlings.... And i tell you everyone is different and individual.... A unique thing of a hand painted item....
Again sorry you had problems....
Hope the ones you have remaining will fill the void of the ones that have been sold.
Michael