Dune (2020) by Dennis Villeneuve

Collector Freaks Forum

Help Support Collector Freaks Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Don’t worry it will flop because there is just no way in hell a story so convoluted with bizarre rituals and characters that have wacky and difficult to remember names will ever penetrate enough to become successful.
That's why they'll dumb it down and from then on there'll be no Dune, just Brian's DUNC. I never saw the names as difficult though. Try reading some EU Star Wars books and attempt to keep track of all the aliens. Now that's hard. Dune has pretty normal names, they're just from certain cultures. Paul and Jessica are everyday ones, things like Leto and Vladimir aren't uncommon. Stilgar, Chani and Lyet are simple enough to remember. But when I was reading the Plagueis novel I couldn't keep track of half the cast, not to mention all the races. Honestly, I've never liked it when they add too many races in their fictional universes. It makes things too complicated, derivative and eventually stale.
It sounds like Dune should be a series on HBO or Netflix.
Old HBO, not current HBO, it'd be the same thing as here. And Netflix? If I had to choose between something I like getting a Netflix adaptation ora decade-long ban across all media, I'd seriously consider the latter.
Yet Joker was one of the most depressing movies I've ever watched and made over $1Billion
Joker also had a much smaller budget and was billed as a drama with a central MC. It was much more depressing, but also more conventional.

Meanwhile Dune is the story of an Aristocrat who goes on a revenge campaign and ends up unleashing a jihad on the entire Empire. There's literally a passage about Paul reading up on Hitler. It's why it's getting sanitised. At its core Dune is about a person with revenge on his mind. That's the bare-bones version. The themes range from environmentalism to the danger of charismatic leaders, but Paul doesn't start as some reluctant hero. And he doesn't end up as much of a "hero" either. In the Antiquity definition, that's alien to the mdoern world, yes. But at the very end he fails even there.

Dune's not more depressing, it's just more "alien". And it's why they're changing it, so that now it'll be the story of a handsome prince, reluctant to assume power, who'll fight the evil Space Nazis and help the poor and opressed "noble savages". It doesn't have the same punch and I'd argue it robs the property of its actual diversity.
 
He is at the end of Snyder's supercut.
Ifhra7X.gif
 
It looks like a perfume commercial. If that is the audience it is going for, it will never be able to cover even the highlights of the source material.

Villeneuve really dropped the ball with 2049. He didn't bother to correct the elephant in the room of Blade Runner nor did he provide a satisfying narrative. He also left loose ends for a sequel than none of us will live to see made.

Ford in a t-shirt is far less problematic than having Deckard alive in the first place. 30 years later, how could he be relevant unless he were main character? He wouldn't. This also proves he was human since he lasted far longer than Replicants can. That is, unless the writer's of 2049 addressed this, which of course they couldn't.

Bombshell question for Blade Runner fans: What do you call a 4 year old human?
Deckard is not a good guy in BR. Is he?

If Dune is handled with this kind of vacancy of understanding, it deserves to be a flop. Let's hope the writer's understand the themes.

It should be mentioned that Frank Herbert worked with Lynch's Dune and that Lynch eventually wanted his name removed from the project because of all the meddling with it.
 
Last edited:
Lol the question of Deckard's nature is more satisfying than any answer.

The fact that you're pissed they didn't answer this shows you didn't appreciate it in the first place.

If they outright said yes he is replicant, a fundamental element of the film would be ruined.

Ridley Scott says he is, Ford disagrees.

The featurette from the 2007 DVD set answers it quite well.
 
Hard to see them making a sequel if it bombs.
Only releasing Pt1 would be a bigger travesty than ending the Snyderverse. But then again this is WB. That said, my guess is principal photography for Pt2 is already in the can, but reshoots and effects work are still holding. If the movie doesn't perform well in the theaters they'll just release the sequel direct to HBOMax streaming.
 
Back
Top