ironwez20
Super Freak
- Joined
- Nov 17, 2008
- Messages
- 27,886
- Reaction score
- 5,913
Why the hate for 3?
8 votes now
Why the hate for 3? O man where have you been for 7 yrs lol
Favorite Spider-Man movie
- Thread starter OSCORP
- Start date
Help Support Collector Freaks Forum:
Why the hate for 3? O man where have you been for 7 yrs lol
He was comedy. Butter fingers!
I'll always love the scene spidey is swinging from the reflection of his shades.
Fair enough they don't explain how Doc Ock can take Spiderman's punches but look at that fight. Brilliant showcase of what you can do with Spiderman. As a sequence it hasn't dated, make it that it never happened in 2004 and put it in a film in 2014 and it'd still be mindblowing.
Last edited:
In the comics superheroes who could punch through walls used to always hold back their punches a bit so as not to knock heads off of bad guys. They never said that Tobey Spidey did that but I have no problem just assuming its the case.
Last edited:
Dark_Knight_89
Super Freak
Are people really using the fact that Spider-Man didn't decapitate Doc Ock with one punch as a critique against the movie?!
Collectorcol
Super Freak
Watching Spider-man 3...Several times and collecting SM3 related items
pturtle
Super Freak
- Joined
- Jun 21, 2013
- Messages
- 10,289
- Reaction score
- 36
That's lazy/bad writing my friend. I like the movie a lot but come on, we shouldn't just have to turn our brains off when we watch these films. Doc Ock being able to trade punches
with a man who sent his high school bully flying down a hallway with one punch makes zero sense.
Something pretty bad happens in TASM2 as well, but I won't bring it up until everyone's seen it.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Put it in spoiler tags.
Dark_Knight_89
Super Freak
Yeah I agree, put it in spoiler tags, what was the bad thing that happened?
Uncanny Web-Slinger
Super Freak
The high school fight In ASM came close, imo
It's a nitpick, but strange how it's quite a prolific nitpick but other just as absurd suspension of disbelief problem in other movies don't garner so much concern.
Like Black Widow grabbing the speeding Chitauri craft without her arm coming off or Batman landing on the roof of the Drug van in TDK caving it in but not hurting hinself or Iron Man not becoming red mush when slammed into the ground inside an iron suit
I'll have to watch it again. I've only seen ASM once, I probably should have watched it again before seeing ASM2.
I was thinking the same thing, but after seeing it once, I felt no desire to ever see it again. I'm not sure I would have the will to sit through it.
pturtle
Super Freak
- Joined
- Jun 21, 2013
- Messages
- 10,289
- Reaction score
- 36
In the beginning when Spidey is trying to stop Rhino while he's driving around the city causing mayhem, Spidey is joking around and doesn't seem to be taking Rhino that serious, he sees Max Dillion about to be crushed by a car that was flying in the air towards him (the scene in the commercial), but that car was previously just rammed by Rhino and whoever was in it is surely dead. Spiderman is still telling jokes and doesn't seem to realize it but I'm guessing this could have been an edit problem or something.
Nova I don't think that the Doc Ock problems is really a nitpick. It's something that happens throughout the film compared to those scenes you mentioned which last for a second. The black Widow scene you named is pretty bad though, but still Doc Ock all of a sudden becoming a supervillain without explanation is a little crazy, and could take someone out of the fight scenes because it's a recurring problem throughout the movie.
Deckard
Super Freak
I think most people will enjoy ASM2 more than the first. For me, the first has a bit tighter overall plot.
Not that 2 is sloppy, just less focused.
I didn't get some of the complaints about the first though. The emotion and relationship felt real and fantastic. It's basically what everyone claims they want, real world motives with comic book action. Being adopted myself, I found the Parker's struggle to be far better portrayed than by Maguire. Didn't get the ****** thing, his relationship to Ben felt very well done, both utmost respect and yet a natural frustration that is neither one's fault.
Not that 2 is sloppy, just less focused.
I didn't get some of the complaints about the first though. The emotion and relationship felt real and fantastic. It's basically what everyone claims they want, real world motives with comic book action. Being adopted myself, I found the Parker's struggle to be far better portrayed than by Maguire. Didn't get the ****** thing, his relationship to Ben felt very well done, both utmost respect and yet a natural frustration that is neither one's fault.
The taxi that almost hits Max yea? The light changed and those guys pulled out into the intersection. Even Giamatti didn't see that hit coming.
Meh, there's a precedent in the comic.
People are generally more durable in comics than in real life. Lots of superheroes (Batman, half of the X-Men, probably a third of the Avengers, 2 of the Fantastic Four, etc. etc.) don't have superhuman strength/armor/etc. so that they could withstand any more pain than a regular person. But it would be a pretty boring comic if the first time Cyclops or Scarlet Witch got smacked by a robot they went down in a heap.
People are generally more durable in comics than in real life. Lots of superheroes (Batman, half of the X-Men, probably a third of the Avengers, 2 of the Fantastic Four, etc. etc.) don't have superhuman strength/armor/etc. so that they could withstand any more pain than a regular person. But it would be a pretty boring comic if the first time Cyclops or Scarlet Witch got smacked by a robot they went down in a heap.
- Joined
- Dec 6, 2011
- Messages
- 5,301
- Reaction score
- 33
I'd have to say the first one, and the second was really good too
pturtle
Super Freak
- Joined
- Jun 21, 2013
- Messages
- 10,289
- Reaction score
- 36
The scene doesn't work for me because Spiderman is joking the whole time, then after he saves Max, the taxi is totaled right near him and he's acting as if someone in there isn't dead, i don't think he even acknowledges the taxi. Then he goes back to joking around, it's a bit strange, and I'm guessing is some sort of a edit problem.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Just felt kind of average and forgettable to me. Hopefully the new one will stick with me a little more. Now that he's not dressed as a basketball, I'll at least try to see this one in the theater.
