General Trek discussion

[afrog]

You're not giving th specific examples because you know you'll get major pushback.

Of course. We are one big happy fleet.​

 

[StarDude]

Of course. We are one big happy fleet.

Come on, spit it out. We asked for the specifics. Without specifics your coming off as a bit unhinged as you wildly defend a position nobody knows.
"this is woke but I won't say specifically why!" Just comes off as crazy. If you can't share your position I'd ask you stop talking because right now you're saying a whole lotta nothing specific. You don't appear to know yourself.

 

[TheClient]

Of course. We are one big happy fleet.​

A request for examples to illustrate your sincerely held opinions is not a trap.

 

[Skyroes]

Come on, spit it out. We asked for the specifics. Without specifics your coming off as a bit unhinged as you wildly defend a position nobody knows.
"this is woke but I won't say specifically why!" Just comes off as crazy. If you can't share your position I'd ask you stop talking because right now you're saying a whole lotta nothing specific. You don't appear to know yourself.

No offence intended here, but is it that important to you? Is the pestering really needed?

He said his peace already, you’re free to disagree. The suggestion that he should “stop talking” is not very “inclusive” is it?

I find piling on someone over such an insignificant thing (a tv show) very unnecessary.

 

[thedarkknight]

 

[StarDude]

He said his peace already, you’re free to disagree. The suggestion that he should “stop talking” is not very “inclusive” is it?

No he didn't. He left it to everyone's imagination. Could be anything. The casting could be woke because it has someone with hair too blonde.

Also it's not about being inclusive. That has nothing to do with anything here, as far as I know, because he never said what he meant specifically.

 

[davejames]

Maybe we should just go back to trashing Section 31 again.

 

[TheClient]

Maybe we should just go back to trashing Section 31 again.

I'd have to watch it first to participate. No thank you.

 

[DParga21]

Maybe we should just go back to trashing Section 31 again.

Agreed.
I find that the people this upset about Trek being "woke" aren't really looking at it through a rational lens.
There is certainly room for debate and modern trek's heading of these topics (I hated how they handled Adira, for instance), but a blanket handwave of "Oh, I hate that Trek went woke" just displays a fundamental lack of understanding of what has always made Star Trek different from just about every other popular franchise in existence.

 

[afrog]

No offence intended here, but is it that important to you? Is the pestering really needed?

He said his peace already, you’re free to disagree. The suggestion that he should “stop talking” is not very “inclusive” is it?

I find piling on someone over such an insignificant thing (a tv show) very unnecessary.

Well, yes, surely I've made my meaning plain.

But clearly some want to continue to carp and to pretend they don't understand. I get it. Unfortunately not much these days can be separated from politics, including religion; and Star Trek which is largely a Hollywood-of-today product is no exception. And I know the political leanings of the majority of Trek fans, particularly the younger ones. A generalization this, yes, but a common sense observation that cannot be refuted. Just search Star Trek online and include political search words. I remember being taken aback, surprised (I should not have been) one day when Youtube-ing this video of the main TNG cast, at least one half dozen, sitting on a stage in Q&A with their audience. I remember, Spiner, Sirtis, Riker I think, I can't remember all of them. Their collective political viewpoints were not at all subtle or benign. In fact it seemed to dominate the conversation. Shatner was also present, he was sitting on the far end stage right. He was comparatively quiet in atypical fashion.

So, the slow "evolution" to a thoroughly woke Trek didn't happen overnight nor did it start with Discovery or the latest movie fiasco, but it has certainly accelerated in the past few years to where we find ourselves today. If this is where you want Star Trek to be, then enjoy. But once again, I am hoping that now that the pendulum has reached amplitude, it will head back toward a centrist position.

 

[TheClient]

Well, yes, surely I've made my meaning plain.

But clearly some want to continue to carp and to pretend they don't understand. I get it. Unfortunately not much these days can be separated from politics, including religion; and Star Trek which is largely a Hollywood-of-today product is no exception. And I know the political leanings of the majority of Trek fans, particularly the younger ones. A generalization this, yes, but a common sense observation that cannot be refuted. Just search Star Trek online and include political search words. I remember being taken aback, surprised (I should not have been) one day when Youtube-ing this video of the main TNG cast, at least one half dozen, sitting on a stage in Q&A with their audience. I remember, Spiner, Sirtis, Riker I think, I can't remember all of them. Their collective political viewpoints were not at all subtle or benign. In fact it seemed to dominate the conversation. Shatner was also present, he was sitting on the far end stage right. He was comparatively quiet in atypical fashion.

So, the slow "evolution" to a thoroughly woke Trek didn't happen overnight nor did it start with Discovery or the latest movie fiasco, but it has certainly accelerated in the past few years to where we find ourselves today. If this is where you want Star Trek to be, then enjoy. But once again, I am hoping that now that the pendulum has reached amplitude, it will head back toward a centrist position.

Your general meaning has been made plan, I agree. Your viewpoint is largely indistinguishable from a vocal portion of modern Trek detractors.

However, you brought up "DEI casting" in the generally better received 1990s shows, DS9 and Voyager. This stood out. My curiosity got the better of me.

I am still very interested to know which minority actors from those shows you feel did not deserve their roles. Which characters would have been better played by white men? If you do not care to name names, so be it. I will embrace the mystery.