Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince--SPOILERS!!!

Collector Freaks Forum

Help Support Collector Freaks Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Re: Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince

I'm worried about Gambon, he's going to have to really deliver on Dumbledore in this one, and he hasn't really done so in the other films.
 
Re: Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince

voldemortkw9.jpg
 
Re: Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince

Love it. :rock

Per Gambon, I have enjoyed his Dumbledore. The only thing I haven't liked about it is how robust he portrays dumbledore... as opposed to original actor who seemed so weak and frail.
 
Re: Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince

Dark, dark, dark. There's a lot of black in these shots and not much color to speak of.

Things are getting bleak for Harry & Co...
 
Re: Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince

I'm worried about Gambon, he's going to have to really deliver on Dumbledore in this one, and he hasn't really done so in the other films.

Here's a bit from a Q&A I was reading, with a tiny quote from Gambon at the end:

Why was Dumbledore angry in the scene where Trelawney was sacked? He shouted, "Don't you have studying to do?!" at the students. Dumbledore is supposed to be a more quirky and benign character but is rather rough and unapproachable in the movie.

It should be noted that Dumbledore never says any such line during this scene in the book and it is rare for him to respond or speak with such bite to his students.

The impression that Dumbledore is angry (throughout the film and especially in that scene), can also be seen as a direct relation to the actor's understanding of the lines and the characters temperament towards others.

In an interview from right before the film premiered, Michael Gambon talks about his experience as a theatre actor and the fact that movies he has done have mostly been for money, not out of interest in the roles.

He also, in other interviews has mentioned that he has not read the books and sees no point in it, since he has the scripts. It seems reading the books would at least give him better insight into his characters development.

Following is an excerpt from the interview:

Q: What makes Dumbledore the greatest wizard of all time?

A: I have no idea. I just say what the script tells me to say. I learn the lines and say them I dont have much sub-text. Theres no sub-text in Harry Potter really, its all magic. Anything can happen.
 
Re: Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince

I find that really surprising as I think he's done a great job as Dumbledore.

Richard Harris was perfect for the first two films where the character was light and playful. But starting with PoA, it started to get darker and I think Gambon stepped in perfectly. I love his emotion and the way he plays the character which I think he could do better than Harris who was great at the sentimental scenes (of which there are a lot in this movie). It will be interesting to see him in this movie as there are a lot of playful moments with Harry and how he delivers.

From the trailer that I've seen, this movie looks great and very true to the book (which I'm rereading right now). I'm sure there will be no Quiditch again to focus on the plot which I can live with. It'll be interesting to see how they handle the
scene at the cave since that really isn't a horcrux but was put there by Serius' brother after he already took it
 
Re: Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince

Some people feel Gambon is too gruff, whereas Harris was kind and gentle and had that wise twinkle in his eye. I think that it would have been interesting to have that kind old grandfatherly figure go through the events of film six, but there's not much we can do with a dead actor. Gambon has been OK in my opinion, and seems less frail and elderly and better able to handle himself in physical scenes like those in films five and six. As the films themselves grow darker, the change in Dumbledores does kind of seem to fit right in.
 
Re: Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince

Some people feel Gambon is too gruff, whereas Harris was kind and gentle and had that wise twinkle in his eye. I think that it would have been interesting to have that kind old grandfatherly figure go through the events of film six, but there's not much we can do with a dead actor. Gambon has been OK in my opinion, and seems less frail and elderly and better able to handle himself in physical scenes like those in films five and six. As the films themselves grow darker, the change in Dumbledores does kind of seem to fit right in.

I felt Harris was PERFECT. Gambon is horrible. That scene you quoted a few posts above shows just why. Why is his Dumbledore so angry? In Goblet of Fire after Harry's name comes out of the Goblet, he is yelling at Harry there too.

Harris would have played both of those scenes calmly and smoothly. I always felt his Dumbledore was always in control and one step ahead of everyone - just like in the books.

Gambon does look an aweful lot like McKellen as Gandalf when he isn't wearing his glasses. I thought your new sig was a sneak pic from the Hobbit at first!
 
Re: Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince

Some people feel Gambon is too gruff, whereas Harris was kind and gentle and had that wise twinkle in his eye. I think that it would have been interesting to have that kind old grandfatherly figure go through the events of film six, but there's not much we can do with a dead actor. Gambon has been OK in my opinion, and seems less frail and elderly and better able to handle himself in physical scenes like those in films five and six. As the films themselves grow darker, the change in Dumbledores does kind of seem to fit right in.

I agree 100%

And Dumbledore was developed after Gandalf so it's kinda fitting that they have a similar look.
 
Back
Top