Of all the 1/6 SW characters, Luke seems to be the one that most prompts deep divisions of opinion on likeness - the "it looks spot-on" vs "I don't see it at all" debate.Yeah I've never understood the love for that BD head. For all it's issues the new sculpt still looks miles better to me.
Pretty much every Luke head - this newest one included - has had this same division.
The DX07 non-BD to me only had a passing MH likeness at best, yet it was adored for years (I remember a few of the high-end guys on here using it to replace the SSC face on the Hoth Luke) and seemed to be the gold standard Luke here. I finally bought one for a steal and... was equally unimpressed in-hand as much as it was in pics.
To me, Liza Minelli hair aisde (and yeah, slightly dated paint apps) the BD DX07 is still the best MH likeness, even if it's so scene-specific it's ridiculous. I also never got the dislike for the HT Luke Jedi head (copper hair aside,) or the like for the "Tooth Skywalker" HT Endor Luke head.