None of them are X-Men
SSC does do some 1/4 Comiquettes, but X-Men Comiquettes are all 95% 1/5 Scale.
Therefore this should be 1/5 to match the existing scale for that format and franchise/team.
Just like the Jim Lee PF range should all be 1/4, if one wasn't collectors of that line would rage about it. So i expect this to be 1/5 to match the 1/5 range its a part of.
*I suppose you could class Namor as an X-Man though
...
As for it being a substitute PF due to the nature of the chaeacter love of being Nekkid, i think they could do the pants he wears in fabric & belt in a 1/4 Jim Lee PF for that line.
True, this is how i'd break it down.
- Those who collect 1/5 X-Men Comiquettes want this to be 1/5 scale and don't mind characters they want getting the 1/4 PF treatment instead as it makes those collectors happy
- Those who collect 1/4 Premium Formats want the 1/5 Comiquette to be a 1/4 PF instead and screw everyone else.
It doesn't matter if they're not X-Men.
Premium Formats are always 1/4, but the thing is the comiquette "rules" have been broken across multiple lines already, including the X-Men.
Spider-Man:
1/4 Com: Spider-Man, Venom, Carnage
14 PF: Spider-Man, Green Goblin
1/5 Com: Back in Black Spidey, Iron Spidey, Hobgoblin
Avengers:
1/4 Com: Iron Man
1/4 PF: Cap, Hulk, Thor, Red Skull, Ms. Marvel, BP, She Hulk, Ultron, Bucky
1/5 Com: Hulk, Iron Man, She Hulk, etc
X-Men:
1/4 Com: Magik
1/4 PF: Wolverine, Rogue, Gambit, Emma (!), Mystique, Colossus
1/5 Com: Emma, Mystique, Darkchild, Back Queen, Wolverine, Psylocke
There's a 1/4 X-Men comiquette. Is the 1/5 line messed up now? (I contend it was never a proper "line" to begin with). Should Magik have been 1/5 because she's a comiquette?
Spidey has a 1/4 PF and 1/4 comiquette. Iron Man and now Illyana (as Magik & Darkchild) have comiquettes in 1/4 and 1/5. Iceman probably wouldn't get a PF based on the costume, and also using the similarly clothed Namor as an example. It's not enough for a PF. There'd be less cloth than Abomination undies due to the smaller size. There will always be exceptions for what works best.
Your break down doesn't include those like me, who collect the 1/4 XMen but will get this anyway because it's a cool piece. 1/4 would have been better, but I like this character and statue. That's what really matters.