Now that all the pics are out, I'll say that this didn't "shock" me. When Pennywise went up the difference between the IA version and the HT one was day and night. The base too was brilliant and really made it feel like a "next level" collectible. A sort of poseable statue. Were I an IT fan, I'd have been all in, no matter the price. This one is good, certainly. There are upgrades which sell it more over the HT. It could be the way the figure is posed and photographed, but I think there are some legitimate differences which kick it up a notch. The weathering on the material, the way they did the leather, some better proportions, it looks more like a mini human and less like a mini replica. And with how pricing is, 80$ more than the HT one for the standard version isn't some huge ammount. True, this one has less accessories, but we rarely ever use anything beyond the basics. I like to have them in the box, but they'll always stay there, so it's not that big a deal for me.
Now, personally I'm passing. I've long since said that I'm waiting for a Battinson 2 and an upgraded costume. I've got way too much on my plate to be spending money on the first costume of what I assume will be a trilogy, and from a movie that I didn't exactly love. Were I to buy one, I'd swing for a standard IA Batman and that'd be it. I don't see the point of rooted hair on a Batman figure since there's little chance I'd ever remove the cowl. For me that option is for the Batman uberfans who have every incarnation, doubles for all the alt looks and so on.
It's not that the HT is worse in that you're comparing, say, Mezcos and Hasbros, it's that IA got the proportions and weathering better so the whole thing comes off more alive. Their photography being better certainly helps. I wouldn't feel left out if I had the HT, but if I were a Batman uberfan, I'd shell out the exta 80 bucks and go for the extra bit of realism. For example, I'm a huge Doom guy, so I'd pay ~1K for a true metal armour version or something to that effect. You just have to find what exactly you want from each figure and character.
But, all things considered, this isn't what I'd consider a game changer. It's a nice figure, it's marginally better, but if this were their first offering, especially with that rough Bruce Wayne with his plasticky hands and hair, we wouldn't be talking about "art". The closeup pic of Battinson's cowl with the flashlight is what really sells this as a "mini human" but can we be sure how much of this is editing? Regardless, for me, it's Pennywise that truly made the jump to the "next level". Joker and Gandalf too, no question. This Battinson is a step bellow them.
As for the Hot "Toys" vs In"Art" thing, I do admit I am quite guilty of it. InArt sounds better than Hot Toys, period, and aesthetics are bound to sway people. I want to believe in some new brand that goes "above". It'd help me cut out on completionism, be more selective, all that. But I can't say that it's entirely fair. One thing we're all ignoring is that so far InArt has been lucky to only work with cloth-based outfits for all their figures. For better or worse HT is all in on Marvel and Star Wars, and thus offers a constant barrage of plasticy, pleather figures which have worn us all out. Sometimes this is entirely HT's fault, case in point the new Endgame Stealth Cap, where they went with a pleather material instead of cloth. But in almost every case, the MCU designs are full of that cheap plastic material that really doesn't translate well. So those figures do end up looking more toyetic. Something that showed HT's current skills is the Loki D+ Loki with his great sculpt and tailored outfit. Had they given him proper rooted hair and those new seamless arms, I think he'd have been an InArt level figure.
My point is, until we see InArt get into the game and start making all those MCU/DCEU/Videogame/Whatever figures with their plastic costumes filled with pleather, we won't know exactly how good they are at tackling it all. Tailoring has its own hurdles, but it's easier to make a figure with real, tailored clothes seem realistic, than it is to true and translate some utterly fantastical getup. I want to see them attempt something like Mass Effect or Halo or whatever else, to see what they're capable of. Do a Darkseid or an Aquaman. You get my point. I want to see them go after the Raimi license and make a truly realistic Spider-Man since HT has dropped the ball there. But until they try a more "wild", comic booky figure, they've yet to be fully tested.
All that said, it's another solid release. It's got its few extra points and I'd buy it over the HT due to the small difference in price and the upgrades. But it's not meltdown worthy. It's solid. Yet the previous releases were more impressive displays I feel. That Wayne specifically is a pretty big let down. They didn't even give him the seamless forearms, and the pegs stick out. It's common practise, but it's not very "next level". The sculpted hair looks very sloppy too. As if they were sure people would only buy the rooted version, and didn't give it the full attention. I myself wouldn't drop 300-400 $ on such a figure. Well, I just hope I didn't make a mistake cancelling my DX19 and losing 100€ to wait for their BaleBat. Seeing this, I think they'll offer a better figure, fixing the small details HT passed over.
Now can they please show that Paul? All of them were supposed to be shown by... May, it was? I don't mind waiting, but after getting the same old, and Battinson hijiking the teaser pic, I need to see them try a genuinely new figure. If they show more LotR over the one new license I'll be disappointed. I wonder if they'll go rooted only, or if they'll attempt the formal attire too next to the stillsuit, similar to how they did Bruce & Batman here. We'll see, I suppose.
PS: I'll say that I'm also a bit disappointed that he didn't get a better base. I thought that all these would be getting more elaborate bases to make them really feel like small museum pieces, but I guess Pennywise needed that to sell him whereas Batman is Batman. It's vastly better than the plastic HT ones, but I wanted each base to be a small diorama.